ALICE WISH LIST SECRET. Report by ERWIN CHLANDA.
Local Government Minister John Ah Kit has been shown a wish list of
major projects for Alice Springs.
The newly formed Regional Development Board has seen it Ð or
compiled it, depending on whom you talk to Ð but neither will say
what's on that list, although it has now been channelled into the NT
government's budget process.
This seems an inauspicious start to the board, directly advising Mr Ah
Kit, consisting of 10 people.
Most of them have been prominent in public life while the town has
stagnated over the past 10 years.
Not one of them has a record of outstanding economic or commercial
achievement, which would give hope that the board will be greater than
the sum of its parts.
The chairwoman is Mayor Fran Kilgariff, who says economic credentials
aren't needed for the job.
She is presiding over people from bodies including the Chamber of
Commerce, Central Land Council, ATSIC, Cattlemen's Association and
CATIA.
Most of them have served on countless boards and committees (work your
way back from Alice in Ten).
While Ð individually Ð their track record in matters economic
is poor or absent, will they Ð collectively Ð come up with
useful advice about the development of our region? It seems Mr Ah Kit
cannot give a dispassionate answer to that.
In fact he's irritated by the mere question.
"They're at the coalface. They have experience.
"They have skills. They have local knowledge," he snapped.
He says this board, and the four others across the Territory, have been
set up to give him direct advice on development issues.
They "won't be toothless tigers" like their predecessors under the CLP
governments, says Mr Ah Kit.
But while budget process is well under way but the board is not.
While the other four boards are said to be up and running, the one in
The Centre still has some vacancies, has met only a couple of times
and, says Ms Kilgariff, "we haven't set our own priorities" although
there is "plenty enthusiasm from the people on the board".
Mr Ah Kit told the Alice News the board delivered the wish list to him
on Friday, February 27.
When we spoke to him on the weekend following he said he hadn't yet
read it.
At first Mr Ah Kit said he would release the list to the Alice News.
Later he said: "I will seriously consider whether I can release that
list to the News."
Later again he said he may not do so because he wouldn't look too good
if some of the projects didn't get up.
Late last week an aide said he would check the "status" of the list
Ð and then didn't get back to us.
Ms Kilgariff said it wasn't the board which gave the list to the
Minister.
In fact it had been compiled by "public servants and other people in
Alice Springs [who] put up their budget considerations to the
government and it is internal government business," said Ms Kilgariff.
"The board has seen that list and at this stage, because we haven't set
our own priorities, we decided we wouldn't be commenting on that list."
So, what's on that list? We asked Ms Kilgariff, wouldn't public
feedback, to her board, about the items on the list be a useful and
democratic thing, now that the government is deliberating about which
items to spend public money on?
Ms Kilgariff: "I do know the list but it's not for me to say.
"It's got nothing to do with the board, that list. It's Cabinet
business.
"We were asked to comment on it, and we decided until we had our own
processes and priorities in place, that we would not be condoning or
otherwise somebody else's list."
One board member says the projects on the list are mainly oriented
towards boosting tourism and work on the Mereenie Loop Road is high on
the agenda.
When asked why he appointed as his development advisers the usual
suspects, people with scant Ð if any Ð economic skills, Mr Ah
Kit seemed to regard the question as an affront.
"I'm born and bred in the Territory, mate," he shot back.
"I've been involved with Aboriginal organisations for 20 years.
"I've been in politics [for several years].
"I know many people out there in the community.
"I know what their standing is in the community in terms of people
speaking highly of them.
"I called for nominations.
"These are the people in the Central Australian region who can advise
me, properly and professionally, on how we can move forward, so Alice
Springs is not left behind as the Territory develops.
"Their track records speak for themselves, if you want to look at them
individually."
What track record?
The land council has been asked to provide a nominee, says Mr Ah Kit.
"The Central Land Council (CLC) has been very entrepreneurial, moving
things forward.
"We see Watarrka [King's Canyon] and the developments there.
"We see Centrecorp, we see the Aboriginal organisations that have been
established, like Arrernte Council, we see the land council in part
ownership with Peter Kittle Motor Company."
The Minister draws a long bow here: Aboriginal money put into
Centrecorp and Peter Kittle almost certainly comes from mining
royalties, principally from gas and oil in Palm Valley and Mereenie.
Aborigines don't have to lift a finger to get those funds.
The Alice News has made many efforts to obtain information about
Centrecorp, owned by the CLC (three fifths), and Tangentyere and
Congress (one fifth each).
But every time we asked the CLC declined to give answers.
"We see the land council as being very important in having a position
on this board," says Mr Ah Kit.
"Some people may say they haven't developed their country as much as
they should have.
"We're a government that wants to work with the Aboriginal
organisations, especially the land councils."
Ms Kilgariff says the board members are appointed as members of the
community.
Four "in part" were selected because they were born in Alice Springs,
and have a "long term commitment to the town".
Why are there no managers on the board with a track record of running
well a big corporation?
"There aren't any big companies such as that in Alice Springs.
"The fact that they haven't nominated means they are a bit too busy.
"I don't believe that you need to be running a big company to have an
interest or expertise in the development of the central region.
"In some ways if you were involved in a large company you would have a
conflict of interest," says Ms Kilgariff.
She says Alice Springs is not stagnating: "It is still growing at point
eight of a per cent."
According to a spokesman for Mr Ah Kit all five boards have been
offered grants to visit similar boards in other parts of the country.
The other four boards have taken up the offer but the Centralian board
has not.
Ms Kilgariff says rather than "traipsing around the country"
representatives from three boards Ð Goldfields Esperance, Kimberley
and Upper Lake Eyre Ð have been invited to give presentations in
Alice Springs.
Her own wish list includes the sealing of the Mereenie Road, a new five
star tourist resort in Alice Springs, "perhaps something like the
Longitude 121" at Ayers Rock; development of the east-west Outback
Highway, and sealing the road from Kingoonya to Streaky Bay.
On the social front Ms Kilgariff is interested in Aboriginal elders
drawing up "cultural by-laws" for itinerants, "what local Arrernte
people might want to tell other people about what behaviour they expect
in Alice Springs".
However, she adamantly rules out enforcement of by-laws by council
staff: "The Alice Springs town council is not going to ask our rangers
to pour out alcohol.
"It is not our job. That belongs to police who are properly trained.
"We are not going to put our rangers into positions where they are
untrained and unprotected."
Why doesn't the council train them?
"Because it's not our job. It's not part of our core responsibility to
be policing alcohol.
"It's a state and Territory function."
WHERE IS TOURISM REALLY AT?
Alice Mayor Fran Kilgariff, now also heading up Local Government
Minister Jack Ah Kit's Regional Development Board for Central
Australia, displays an amazingly casual attitude towards the facts and
figures of the town's major industry, and the one with enormous growth
potential Ð tourism.
"I don't believe tourism is stagnant," she says.
"I think international tourism has dropped a little, but there are more
backpackers here than there used to be.
"And a lot of tourism businesses are actually doing well.
"It's not across the board. There are some that are doing well.
"A lot of tourism operators are actually very optimistic around town.
"I don't believe it is stagnating."
Does she have any figures?
No, not with her at the time of our interview. And she makes no offer
to provide them later.
The lack of data is a worry because, as Ms Kilgariff says, "the council
spends a lot of money developing tourism, hundreds of thousands of
dollars a year.
"We facilitate, we provide money, we make sure that the town looks
good, clean, tidy, that the infrastructure and facilities are up to
scratch."
As the council is obviously flying blind with their investment in
tourism, what does the ratepayer get for all this money?
Ms Kilgariff would be hard pressed to say because there are no figures
for the town of Alice Springs, at least not recent ones.
This is an issue prominent tourism figures have repeatedly criticised
publicly, and about which the town council has done nothing.
Ms Kilgariff's fellow board member, CATIA's Craig Catchlove, could tell
her the NT Tourism Commission (NTTC) doesn't provide statistics for
Alice Springs, only for Central Australia, and that, of course,
includes the Ayers Rock Resort.
Mr Catchlove says "there is very little real growth" in the Alice Ð
but that's based on anecdotal evidence.
According to CATIA the NTTC provided visitor numbers in Alice Springs
for 1995 to 2001, as follows:
95/96 - 349,00096/97 - 301,00097/98 - 304,00098/99 - 389,00099/00 -
320,00000/01 - 368,000The "best guess" average income in those years
was $150m a year Ð no hard figures, though.
And then came September 11, Bali, Ansett, SARS, Afghanistan and Iraq
Ð but we have no numbers, no bed nights, no dollars for the town
for that crucial period.
"We provide money for conferences, we sponsor the Masters Games, we put
money into tourism initiatives, such as Tourism Futures," says Ms
Kilgariff Ð but to what avail?
The Mayor says the council has lobbied the government on all sorts of
issues: "I'm quite happy with the $27.5m that is going into tourism
promotion, the hundreds of thousands of dollars the government has put
into promotion of Virgin in the last six months.
ENTHUSIASM"I firmly believe that tourism is going to grow in Alice
Springs.
"Alice Springs as a destination has to be marketed with more
enthusiasm.
"What we are at the start of is looking at a brand for Alice Springs.
"Amazing Alice is a great idea," says Ms Kilgariff.
" Perhaps it's a process of building on that.
"There are a number of people around town who are doing their own thing
in terms of the brand, and promoting the brand.
"I think the days of frontier image are long gone.
"We're no longer a frontier outback town but something that reflects
Alice Springs as a go-ahead, innovative, creative, bustling town, a
centre of excellence, an enthusiastic, vibrant, go-ahead town."
All we need now are the facts to back all this up.
LIBRARY IN CROSS FIRE AS COUNCIL OFFICES SET TO GO AHEAD. Report by
KIERAN FINNANE.
While the public library, urgently needing to double its floor space,
has had its new building put on hold to a future second stage, council
administration will get their new offices in Civic Centre redevelopment
plans put on display last week.
The plans also reveal that a public ablutions block will be built
fronting Todd Street.
There'll be a new, larger and more functional Garden Room, also facing
Todd Street.
The present chambers will become council's reception area, while the
present reception area will be refurbished as chambers that can also be
used for community purposes.
A new building to house council administration will extend from the
reception area eastwards and has been designed to fit in with the
Afghan theme of the existing building.
It will overcome the present "serious overcrowding" in the admin
offices and replace plant, equipment and engineering systems that have
reached their use-by date.
NEEDS"The aim has been to provide a modern administration building and
community facilities that will meet our needs for the next 10 to 20
years," says Roger Bottrall, council's director of planning and
infrastructure.The council lawns and palm trees will remain, with
paving in the corner towards Todd Mall.
The south-western corner, opposite KFC, will become the site for a new
public library, but that won't be built until funds are found further
down the track.
Carparking between the proposed library and Leichardt Terrace will be
formalised, providing 300 places for the public and council staff.
The south-eastern corner will be landscaped, leaving existing large
trees in place.
The courtyard containing the amphitheatre will be enclosed and no
longer available to casual users. It will, however, be available for
community functions.
All of this, in a design by national firm Gutteridge Haskins &
Davey, now awaits public comment over the coming month.
GHD won the tender on the basis of their "proven record in the design
of public buildings", says Mr Bottrall.
Community consultation till now was not thought warranted because the
main changes will be internal and are operational, not community
issues, says Mayor Fran Kilgariff.
She also says that extensive consultation undertaken by the previous
council was taken into account.
"When we tried to incorporate all that the community wanted, we came up
with a design that would have cost $12.5m.
"We simply did not have access to that amount of money and decided to
go for renovation instead."
The estimated price tag for this first stage of the redevelopment is
$6m, which will come from council's funds.
Alderman Bob Corby, on the Civic Centre sub-committee together with the
mayor and aldermen Jenny Mostran, Geoff Bell, David Koch and Raelene
Beale (until recently), could not remember the exact arrangement for
community consultation Ð "that was left up to staff".
But he says "the appropriate consultation will be forthcoming" now that
the plans are on display.
Ald Mostran says, apart from reviewing the previous consultation, the
sub-committee worked with the Arid Lands Environment Centre and Cool
Communities on the energy issues of the redevelopment. As a result, the
design on display, using passive design features such as north-south
orientation and sub-floor ventilation, has a four star energy
efficiency rating.
The community now has a chance to respond to detailed plans and she
hopes they will: "The Civic Centre has to be community-owned. We don't
want to put the plans out there and have them ignored," says Ald
Mostran.
She joined the sub-committee to "push the toilet issue".
TOILETS
She is convinced that having the toilets prominently placed and well
lit will deal with a lot of "the negative issues" of the present
facility.
She says this has been the experience of other regional centres, such
as Broome and Port Augusta.
"But if a lot of people say, Ôwe want you to hide the toilet
away', we would have to pay them some attention," says Ald Mostran.
Mayor Kilgariff says there will be grassroots consultation about the
new library. Council has approached the Territory Government for
financial assistance to build it and she hopes the process will begin
next year.
As a stand alone building the new library would have the potential to
reflect a different theme.
"There is scope to make it a more Indigenous themed building," says Ms
Kilgariff.
It could also present the opportunity for greater orientation towards
Todd River.
"But would you then want a carpark on the corner of Todd Street and
Stott Terrace?" asks Mr Bottrall.
Ms Kilgariff says orientation towards the river was "not a high
priority" for the first stage of the development.
She also says access to the library would probably be best from Todd
Street.
Debate about the present library has intensified over recent months,
with Ald Corby notably expressing concern at unpleasant odours,
visitors eating and sleeping, being barefoot, and children being
unsupervised.
Library manager, Glenys Aird, confirms that some users of the library
have complained about these matters, but she says other visitors have
commended the library on the work they have done to make the library
accessible to the whole community.
"The increase in library usage, almost double in five years, has
largely come from Aboriginal people, which is extraordinary in terms of
public libraries in Australia," says Ms Aird.
She says library staff "mounted a vigorous case" to have the library
included in Stage One of the redevelopment, as current visitation
requires a doubling of floor space to cope with numbers and the
different types of usage.
"We thought a new library for the whole community would be the best way
to spend the money available, even though we acknowledge that the
administration desperately needs new office space," says Ms Aird.
"We accept council's decision and we are working to address some of the
issues within the constraints of using the existing building for
another five years."UNAWARE
Ms Aird says she is unaware of council's approach to the government for
funding for a new building, although she knows such an approach has
been "mooted".
On the library staff's request of council, Mayor Kilgariff says the
sub-committee considered it "not feasible" because the approach was
only made "in the last couple of weeks and at that stage the
redevelopment plans were "too far advanced".
Ald Corby's motion at council's end of February meeting, that
enforcement of by-laws regarding hygiene, dress and behaviour standards
in the library be investigated, was carried.
Council is now awaiting a report from officers on the issue.
Ms Kilgariff says she is "certainly not in favour of dress codes or
security guards" in the library, and does not believe that staff want
that either.
SUCCESSFUL"We have a definite policy of equity of access to the library
and the implementation of it with regard to Aboriginal people has been
particularly successful," says Ms Kilgariff."Until we have a new
library there may be some other options to help deal with the problems
that have arisen."These could include employing more staff, modifying
the air conditioning, providing more cleaning, all of which cost money
and should be considered as part of the budget process."
Ald Corby says he is waiting for the officers' report before making
further comment.
Ald Mostran says it is important to find "inclusive" solutions to the
problems at the library. She did not rule out "dress standards"
although "they would have to come from the community, not from me".
"The library is a pivotal service that council offers.
"We need to think about what it is used for and to talk to all user
groups to see what common ground there is."
Ms Aird says library staff have also suggested that they work with
Aboriginal organizations to address some of the issues, including
appropriate staffing and child-care.
They are already talking to the Education Department about school-age
children who are in the library on schooldays.
More immediately, they are also working on changing the present layout
to create some "quiet zones", which should be completed by the end of
May.
Ms Aird says public libraries throughout the world are places for "the
disenfranchised, safe havens as well as repositories of history and
culture and sources of information".
This social and community focus means that consultation on what the new
library should be like should be put in place from the beginning, a
chance also, says Ms Aird, "to sell the concept of the public library
to the community again".
CRUNCH TIME IN BUSH CHANCE FOR MAISIE? Report by ERWIN CHLANDA.
Maisie Austin OAM says it's crunch time in Aboriginal affairs and that
augurs well for her candidacy in Lingiari.
As a woman and as an Aborigine Ms Austin would be fighting an uphill
battle as the CLP candidate for Lingiari, the predominantly black seat
taking in all of the Territory except Darwin.
But she says the long entrenched power structure Ð a Labor Member
backed by the land councils Ð has achieved so little for the folk
in the bush that they are looking for fundamental change.
If that's true the softly spoken businesswoman from Darwin Ð the
first Aboriginal owner of a real estate business, she says with a smile
Ð may be on her way to Canberra.
Ready to split her domicile between Darwin and Alice, where she has
"strong Aboriginal family connections", the Wardaman / Jaywon
descendant, a former director of an insurance loss adjusting company
for about 20 years, owner of boutiques, and a martial arts school for
25 years, has previously been the CLP's second Senate candidate,
offering no chance of victory.
But now she's in the main game: She says she needs a mere five percent
swing to unseat Labor's Warren Snowdon.
She concedes that standing a black candidate in a black seat has its
problems.
The candidate, of course, gets support from his or her own family, but
other clans may be hostile.
Tribal tension would come into play Ð not a recipe for victory: It
seems better to have a non-Aboriginal politician, with a proven empathy
for his constituents, who can impartially take issues to the
Parliament.
And that, after all, has been whitefeller business, and politics, by
and large, rightly or wrongly, has been men's business. That means
being a woman is an additional handicap.
Good examples of successful pollies, because they are white men, in a
black seat are former Territory Member for MacDonnell, Neil Bell
(Labor), a fluent Pitjantjatjara speaker, and his CLP successor John
Elferink (coincidentally a friend of Ms Austin's), popular in the bush
whilst not carrying any "rellies" baggage.
In 2001 Mr Elferink defeated Central Land Council (CLC) figure and
Aborigine Harold Furber.
Ms Austin says there is now a growing trend amongst Aboriginal people
to call off all political bets because of the sustained misery in
Aboriginal society, and the manifest failure of the land councils and
sitting politicians in bringing about change.
"Times are changing, and attitudes of men, too, realising that the
leaders don't necessarily have to be men," says Ms Austin.
"It's for me to go and change the attitude and the psyche of Aboriginal
people to see that you don't have to be a man to fight for the rights
of people.
"Sometimes a woman's voice can be a lot stronger."
Ms Austin says there are fewer regional elements, opportunities for
pork barrelling, in Federal elections: "The issues affect equally
nearly all the clans and communities, right across the NT.
"They are generic issues," she says, indigenous education, housing and
health, substance abuse, economic development Ð the old, unchanging
litany of black misery.
"I would like to be able one day to show Aboriginal people a window of
opportunity, to create a better lifestyle for them, and gain self
esteem, feel good about who they are.
"Community leaders have to start helping their own communities."
She readily admits that the perception was that her own party, in 26
years in power, neglected or mismanaged Aboriginal affairs in the
Territory.
"There is a perception that the CLP was a red neck boys' club that
didn't necessarily promote Indigenous people and issues.
"So what I say now is that things are no longer as they used to be.
"The fact that they have preselected me as a candidate is a step in
changing the psyche and attitude of the party.
"The CLP needed to change its attitude.
"The feeling in the CLP now is really exciting with Terry Mills as the
leader.
"There is a new committee, younger people with new ideas, they have
listened to the community.
"They are trying to make changes, win the confidence of the community."
But Ms Austin says Aboriginal people must "start helping themselves".
"They can't keep blaming somebody else.
"They really need to realise what assets and talents they themselves
have in their own community, and stand up and be counted, saying we can
do this, we can get out of this psyche, this lifestyle that we've been
in for so many years.
"They've got to be serious, too.
"I'd like to see the community councils be given the incentive,
encouragement and assistance to solve problems themselves."
LET'S OWN OUR PROBLEMS AND STOP THE WHINGING. Report by COURTNEY
WHITMAN.
This is part two of COURTNEY WHITMAN's interview with Aldermen Annette
Smith, who has yet to make up her mind about standing again for
council, and Aldermen Geoff Bell, who'll "probably" stand. (See part
one in last week's issue.)
On land shortage and its impact on real estate prices, reacting perhaps
to recent statements in these pages by Alds Mostran and Jones, Ald
Smith says "it's not the government's problem, it's ours".
She wants to know why council thinks it has to constantly run to
government.
"The whole thing needs rethinking," she says.
Ald Bell, however, thinks council has done "really well so far in
lobbying [government] to get the town rocking and rolling again" with a
land release.
As a local initiative to promote tourism, Ald Bell helped found the
Ambassadors to Alice Springs project, which recognizes the contribution
of local business people to the promotion of Alice.
Peter Seidel, Executive Officer of the Camel Industry Association was
the first honorary ambassador in September of 2003, and Wayne Kraft was
recognized recently as the second.
Their jobs involve them in talking up the town and region when they are
away, "fostering business, tourism, and cultural" networks.
However, Ald Smith is critical of council for having "no formal policy"
on how "tourism is to be promoted and supported."
She also finds the lack of community involvement in council meetings
very "discouraging".
"It's the ones that never come in that say the most," says Ald Smith,
referring to the whinging in letters to the editor and people generally
complaining about the town.
"I find it very disheartening," she says. "I'm sick of people trying to
find fault here. There are a lot of happy, well adjusted people here.
"We need to iron out wrinkles, but why would people like us be here if
it's not OK to live here?
"The schools are great. I don't know why we undermine the town, and
ourselves."
Both say time is the biggest consideration for people thinking about
standing for council. Ald Smith adds commitment, " absolute
commitment".
"You have to be contactable and reachable, you've got to read, do your
homework," she says.
Ald Bell agrees, "There are times when your time is infringed upon, but
if you feel like you've got something to say, have a go."
Ald Smith stresses that differences make council stronger.
"We need diversity in council," she says.
"People should never think they haven't got what it takes.
"Everyone's got a skill. Council is an amalgam of skills."Ald Bell
urges prospective aldermen to take advantage of information sessions
that council will be holding, wishing that he'd been offered one before
he ran.
FOOTY BOSS BACKS ANOTHER WINNER! Report by PAUL FITZSIMONS.
Mildie Raveane had a weekend he'll never forget, when after hosting the
Collingwood versus Port Power match as Chairman of AFLCA (the good old
CAFL) he was able to watch part of his superannuation portfolio,
Chigwidden, stroll to the line at Pioneer Park on Saturday afternoon
paying $7.
The face of the Crown Plaza, Mildie has talked up Chigwidden's
potential, racing in Darwin last Cup time or down south over the
summer. Algie Trengrove had the horse in Adelaide, but in resuming at
Pioneer Park the "Razor" Terry Gillett has successfully taken over
training duties.
In the 1100 metre Schweppes Maiden, She's a Card trained by Catriona
Green, was set to make it three wins in a row for the stable when the
speedster jumped to the front. Rustic Outlook joined her at the lead,
however, and this may have told on the filly's performance.
Come the turn Litigious made a run and straightened up looking the
goods, but Chigwidden, who had camped mid field in the running found
plenty, and came down the middle of the course under a full head of
steam to score by two and a quarter lengths. Litigious held on for
second, while the favourite She's A card filled third place.
Earlier in the day, the 1000 metre Maiden Two Year old was run. Unlike
last year when Drifter proved to be a star performer, it seems this
year's crop of two year olds are more evenly set. Tim Norton took the
favourite Crown Pilot to the lead from barrier one, while Leeches,
Sharmoxie, and Thin Red Rag raced as a group about two lengths off the
pace. At the business end of the race Leeches pulled out plenty and was
able to overpower Crown Pilot to win by half a length. The favourite
took second money and Sharmoxie filled the placings.
Scott Leckey from Darwin then enjoyed a riding double under the
instructions of trainer Catriona Green. In the 1400 metre Redbank Class
Two Handicap, Leckey had the mount of Pierrot, a well bred performer
who is resuming after an extended spell from the track.
The apprentice threw caution to the wind and led on Pierrot, enjoying a
pressure free run two to three lengths in front. In fact as the race
went on the challenges didn't and Pierrot strolled to the winning post,
four and three quarter lengths in front of the equal favourite Burran,
with Aldilar a further three and three quarter lengths back in third
spot.
The Green / Leckey combination then buttered up in the Absolute Steel
Class Five Handicap over 1200 metres when Cartoon Hero saluted. In the
running the favourite Edge to Edge settled off the pace with Mr Cardin,
allowing Gold Boss to dictate terms in front. Being more a 1400 metre
horse Cartoon Hero was further back, but it became a different story in
the straight. As they went to the line Cartoon Hero had too much
strength for Mr Cardin and recorded a one and a quarter length win.
Third place was filled by Gold Boss, with Edge to Edge a disappointing
fourth.
The last of the day, the Castlemaine Perkins Open handicap over 1000
metres, had punters marking their black books after Our Mate Jack lived
up to favouritism and scored by two and a quarter lengths. Crazy Cotton
led with Ganga back, and Our Mate Jack in third place.
Crazy Cotton called it a day at the top of the straight leaving it to
Ganga and Our Mate Jack to make their moves. In the style that has
taken Our Mate Jack from maiden to open company in just 12 months, the
favourite went to the line looking good for the Cup time sprint.
Ganga finished second and the veteran Le Saint came from last to
collect for third place. The win also gave a riding / training double
to Tim Norton and Gillett.
Azaria still with us. COLUMN by ANN CLOKE.
The adage, the truth is often stranger than fiction, is a huge
understatement.
There have been occasions when David and I have travelled, whether it's
interstate or overseas, that as soon as we reveal we live in the Alice,
questions, apart from the usual (Do we have sealed roads? Are there
shops and schools here?!), are asked about the dingo, the missing baby
and Ayers Rock. I was interested to read an article in the Oz, 4/3/4,
Media section, New Light on Dark Mystery, re a script based on the case
against Lindy and Michael Chamberlain, written by film maker Tony
Cavanaugh and his Liberty Productions partner, his wife, Simone North.
Months of research, plus interviews with hundreds of people to ensure
accuracy, will now hopefully culminate into Liberty's production of a
mini series for the Seven Network.It brought to mind a conversation a
couple of years ago when David and I were with friends, Anne, William,
Hermann and Ruth (who have since left the Centre to retire in Clare),
Stephanie, John, Mandy, Ian and others, on a balmy Sunday evening
enjoying sundowners under a huge Centralian sky.
William asked who amongst us was living in Alice back in 1980 when
little Azaria disappeared Éwhich turned out to be the majority
of those present Éexcept William and Anne, who were still in the
middle of southern Africa, as was David. William posed two questions:
Did we believe that Lindy was guilty at the time?
If so, did we change our minds when she was released, and subsequently
pardoned, after serving three years in Berrimah?
In a relatively orderly fashion, everyone around the table answered.
There was an overwhelming belief from those assembled that she had not
taken her baby's life.
Perhaps she knew more, but she was certainly innocent of the crime of
which she was accused.
Sometime later, I read that Lindy had erected a bronze sculpture in a
special place in the middle of her garden on the property in New South
Wales which she shares with her husband: a celebration of a precious
life, tragically shortened, a water fountain of a baby bathing, in
memory of little Azaria.
The Weekend Oz magazine, October 19/20, 2002, ran an article: "Dingoes
and Divas Ð the making of a Rock Opera called Lindy", giving the
background, for the few who didn't already know it, to the show which
was opening at the Sydney Opera House that week.
Composer Moya Henderson wrote the stage play over a ten year period,
courageously battling and overcoming public opinion, emotions, casting
and production problems, to put together the work.
Lindy Chamberlain was involved with the production, making changes and
corrections to ensure that the story line paralleled, as closely as
possible, reality, making certain that her first words, that now famous
sentence:
A dingo's taken my baby, were written into the script.
The 1988 film, Cry in the Dark, released in Oz as Evil Angels, was well
attended and showed that the mystery and intrigue surrounding the
Azaria incident hasn't diminished with time.
It's easy to forget that it really happened, it's not a fairy-tale with
an ugly ending.
It was 1982: Max Rainer was the manager of the Alice Springs Bowling
Club and I was (self-appointed) assistant manager É keeping the
accounts and running the bar.
Dennis Barrett, (since deceased) Magistrate of the Alice Springs Court
and Frank Gibson, (also deceased), one of the Police Officers who was
on duty when little Azaria disappeared, used to play competition lawn
bowls most weekends.
It was an extremely volatile time and the townspeople in general were
angry Ð emotions ran high, accusations were rife and there were
ugly scenes outside the Alice Springs Courthouse.
Lindy was persecuted, hounded by the media and the hearing, for
security purposes, was relocated to Darwin.
Months after Lindy was found guilty and sentenced to gaol, both Dennis
and Frank revealed that they had always believed she was innocent.
People are punished daily because of public perceptions, prejudice and
outcry.
In May a man called Murdoch will stand trial for the murder of Peter
Falconio, the young British tourist who disappeared south of Barrow
Creek on July 14, 2001.
Joanne Lees, his travelling companion, was also under scrutiny, not
quite accused, but almost, when she first recounted her story about the
incidents surrounding the disappearance of her lover.
We have become a nation of sceptics, even though we are aware that
bizarre and tragic events continue to happen in this remote part of Oz.
The events surrounding Azaria's disappearance were even stranger Ð
the world looked on, pointed fingers and judged Ð it will make
interesting viewing, twenty odd years on, to see the story as perceived
by Liberty Productions.
Your Oscar is in the mail. COLUMN by STEVE FISHER.
Wouldn't it be better if the Oscars were run differently?
Academy members would be sent forms that invited them to vote. They
would tick the boxes and return the forms.
Then the prizes would be worked out and the golden statuettes
despatched to the winners in padded brown envelopes by registered post.
Actors would briefly stop work on their latest film to accept the award
and to have a small black-and-white photo taken.
The picture would later appear in the Academy annual report.
No need for a massive ceremony and all the mindless sparkle that
surrounds it.
The benefits of this process are obvious.
The general public wouldn't have to watch entertainment professionals
giving themselves yet more awards.
We wouldn't have to suffer overwrought speeches by highly-strung actors
in clothing that doesn't fit.
But most of all, the whole process would be more efficient, meaning
that the same result is achieved for much less effort.
There, that's sorted out then. Next week; cookery on television.
Let's go back to reading recipes in food-stained, dog-eared paperback
books instead.
Making the Oscars more efficient appeals mainly to beige management
types who don't get out enough.
For example, I was reading a management article recently that rated the
efficiency of countries in a league table.
The conclusion of the analysis was that the much higher productivity of
the United States compared to competing nations was solely due to the
willingness of the workforce to have short holidays of eight working
days a year on average.
Even the Germans, with their reputation for discipline and a powerful
work ethic, make sure they get at least three times the recreation
leave of the Americans.
Here in the Alice, far from the Land of Eight Days Leave, people broker
a nice line of self-deprecating jokes about how inefficient the place
is. Have you heard the one about meetings always being late due to the
Territory time difference?
What about the oft-repeated remark about the consignment that is always
bound to arrive sometime Next Tuesday (or NT).
Or the comment about there being no such thing as a punctual Territory
tradesman.
I might be a fish out of water, but I reckon I've heard them all.
Jokes about how shabby we are. Just one symptom of an inferiority
complex that probably afflicts most places located far from the
frenetic and dynamic cities where clearly all the clever people must
live and work.
But, then again, inferiority depends on where your benchmarks are and
with whom you are comparing.
To take just two fine groups of people, I have heard that both
Buddhists and Cubans live for the moment.
They try to enjoy what they are doing and don't spend much time
planning for or worrying about what's around the corner.
In Cuba, for most people the future doesn't bear thinking about (more
long months with no money).
And for Buddhists, to focus on the future they would lose the chance to
savour what is happening right now.
So I reckon that the problem for Territory culture is that too many
people make excuses and jokes for sloppiness.
We need to borrow from the Cubans. Instead of blaming the heat or the
remoteness or some other lame excuse, it's far better to claim proudly
that lateness and inefficiency are just vital aspects of local culture
that outsiders are far too shallow to understand.
After all, the supposedly sophisticated and business-like people who
organise the Academy Awards or the Allan Border Medal or any of those
other back-slapping events don't suffer from an inferiority complex
about sloppiness and inefficiency.
So why should we? And if you're expecting an award, it should arrive
sometime Next Tuesday.
steve@afishoutofwater.com
40 YEARS, STILL DREAMING. Review by KIERAN FINNANE.
People of the Bidyadanga community, also known as La Grange, were
removed from their desert homelands in WA some 40 years ago, yet when
they began painting in the mid-nineties their traditional country was
still their subject.
Bidyadanga artists will be among the stars of Gallery Gondwana's first
exhibition of 2004, Divas of the Desert, not least because their work
Ð fresh, vibrant, colourful and distinctive Ð underlines the
ongoing vitality of Aboriginal art.
Divas will become an annual feature of the Gallery Gondwana program,
honouring the work of women artists, who as they paint, indeed do "sing
their country" Ð recalling the journeys and events of mythological
ancestors as they ventured across the landscape during the Tjukurrpa.
This year's Divas presents a body of some 50 paintings from, apart from
Bidyadanga, Warlayirti Artists (Great Sandy Desert), Mankaja Arts
(Fitzroy Crossing), Maruku Arts & Crafts (Uluru), Utopia Artists
(Eastern Desert), and Warlukurlangu Artists (Tanami Desert), as well as
Alice Springs.
It features both established senior law women Ð including Eubena
Nampitjin, Elizabeth Nyumi, Narputta Nangala, Alice Nampitjinpa, Molly
Rogers, Cory Surprise, Kathleen Petyarre, Betsy Lewis and Dorothy
Napangardi Ð and emerging artists, such as Julie Robinson, Weaver
Jack, Bertha Linty and Eadie Curtis.
COTTONAlso showing will be Minymaku Cloth, reflecting a new approach to
textile art in 12 2.5m lengths of silk and cotton by six Pitjantjatjara
women from Amata in northern South Australia.
And, as if all this isn't exciting enough, fibre, bronze and prints
from Maningrida (on the coast of Central Arnhem Land) will round out
the show.
They include examples of "new directions" by Maningrida artists,
following their association with Urban Art Projects (UAP).
This lead to incorporation of hard-edged media, in particular, cast
bronze and aluminium in sculptures of echidnas, bush mice and pig, camp
dogs and turtles by some of Maningrida's most accomplished and talented
artists, such as Lena Yarinkura, Bob Burruwul and Lena Djamarrayku.
Exhibition opens this Friday, 5.30 Ð 7.30pm.
Return to Alice Springs
News Webpage.