Alice Springs News, December 21, 2006
ALICE SPRINGS NEWS,
December 21, 2006. This page contains all major
reports and comment pieces in the current edition.
WHAT A YEAR! By ERWIN CHLANDA.
In 2006 Alice Springs got to within a bee's whisker of tipping point.
In 2007 we'll be making the crucial decisions which will take us in one of two directions.
One would take us towards prosperity and social harmony built on a tourism industry of global renown, a resort town with strong links into the bush (thanks to reform of the Land Rights Act), an industry blossoming with our magnificent environment, our vibrant history and culture, Indigenous traditions and world fame.
The other path would be to a town of service personnel for a dysfunctional society - judges, police officers, jail wardens, doctors, social workers and so on.
Their residential compound will be surrounded by a tall fence outside which there is violence, boredom, anger and rubbish. Tourism will be just a memory.
Farfetched?
Pay a visit to a town camp like Hoppy's, Hidden Valley or the Warlpiri Camp. And just reverse the population percentages.
Down which path will we go? We can still decide - but time's running out.
2006 was when the town's general public began to understand the meaning of "urban drift", much as mainstream Australia cottoned on to global warming.
But as the environmental tipping point is still a few years away, crunch time in Alice Springs is upon us right now.
Productive members of the community are moving out, and many of those who are moving in are unemployable welfare dependents.
Thousands of them.
The incompetence of our leaders - the Alice Town Council and the NT Government - has become painfully evident.
Item One: In May the Federal Government, through Aboriginal Affairs Minister Mal Brough, offered millions of dollars for long overdue facilities to accommodate itinerants in a civilised manner.
Seven months later neither the council nor the NT Government have been able to gain public acceptance of two locations for these camps. This is a pathetic farce considering we're in the middle of a million square kilometres of practically empty land.
Item Two: Urban drift is all of a sudden seen as something quite inevitable.
How come? And are we prepared for it?
Why have we mot made clear what conduct is required for the privilege of living in this town?
Would Chamonix, France, or Aspen, Colorado, or even Ayers Rock Resort, NT, allow people to sleep in parks, shout in the street, stagger around drunk, beg, fight, urinate in public?
Last week there was a mass brawl in Parsons Street, which disgusted and frightened locals and tourists alike.
How many people were arrested? None.
How may people were charged? None.
They were "moved on", say the police. (The "feuding" parties have since agreed to stop fighting.)
Yet it's not all bad.
The leadership crisis has already prompted the formation of a promising lobby group, Advance Alice.
Three people have signalled their interest in the mayor's job, 15 months ahead of the election: David Koch, Murray Stewart and Chris Vaughan.
It's significant that all are successful business people, and all are tough on law and order.
The incumbent, Fran Kilgariff, is widely regarded as a nice person.
But she needs to make up her mind whether she wants to be a defender of Alice Springs, against a government blithely selling us down the gurgler, or to join that government as a Member of Parliament.
She can't have it both ways.
Looking at the bright side:-
Thousands of people have stood up against the Chief Minister's plan to surrender ownership of national parks to an Aboriginal minority, a proposal that now seems doomed, courtesy Mr Brough.
The tourism lobby CATIA has a more assertive leadership.
Steve Brown, a member of the pioneering family at White Gums, has formed Advance Alice. One of the mayoral hopefuls, Murray Stewart, is the vice-president.
If the group provides a valve for the pent-up frustrations of being ignored by the high and mighty, and gives the public a fair opportunity to air its views, for example, expressed at public meetings open to all, then the group will become a powerful institution in 2007.
There are enough people of substance in Advance Alice to lend force to demands formulated democratically.
Advance Alice seems set to become a far more appropriate alternative to the public service dominated Alice in Ten which has no significant runs on the board.
Other bright points on which to build a great future for the town are the electrifying boom of home-grown art and entertainment.
Indigenous artists continue to excite attention around the world. Black creativity is diversifying into music and film, to acclaim.
Independent non-Indigenous film-makers are combining talents to bear witness to the region's phenomena and tell its stories.
New levels of excellence have been reached in wearable arts.
Teenage bands like Moxy and Zenith belt out original music; 150 people - a number Sydney and Melbourne can only dream of except for a top-selling author - attend the launch of a third book published by local writers; students at Centralian College and CDU produce outstanding short films.
And Red Dust Theatre, founded by Craig Mathewson, is reaching for the stars as Danielle Loy gives up her day job as a lawyer, to put on plays she says will attract audiences well beyond The Centre.
Go for it, guys!
"URBAN DRIFT" BEGINS AND ENDS 2006 FOR COUNCIL . By KIERAN FINNANE.
If there was doubt in any alderman's mind at the start of 2006 about whether council should become involved in tackling the broad social and economic issues of the town, the intervening months would have laid such doubt to rest.
In the context of widespread feeling that Alice Springs is neglected and misunderstood by the Territory and Federal governments, the community has demanded that council fill the shoes of government closest to the people.
The year opened with the issue still on everybody's lips, "urban drift", which had made its presence felt over last summer.
On February 16 the Alice News reported that a senior public servant believed the Territory Government was set to move 5000 to 7000 Aboriginal people from bush communities to Alice Springs, with remote councils being "starved out of existence".
By the next week the council's new head ranger Kevin Everett was saying that he'd been told to select two areas in the town with a view to set up camping areas for Aboriginal people who had been streaming into Alice Springs since the preceding October.
He said the proposed areas were planned to be at the northern and southern entrances to the town, about five to eight hectares, with a fence, lights, ablution blocks, shelters and fire places.
Unhappy with his frank talking, the council shut Mr Everett down, but he'd already articulated the major issue of 2006 and its supposed solution, still dangerously unresolved.
As it has panned out the council has not had to take much initiative on dealing with urban drift (big Mal blew in and took over) but when they have acted, it's pointed up the difficulty of being expected to respond to the community's concerns while not really having the wherewithal to do so.
This gets them doing things like writing letters to the powers that be which might seem like a pain free option until it gets them in hot water.
APPROVED
Thus the letter to Mal Brough, Federal Minister for Indigenous Affairs, objecting to the Dalgety Road site for one of the proposed "donga" facilities, apparently forgetting that council had two representatives (the mayor and her deputy Robyn Lambley) on the committee that had provisionally approved the site as well as not realising that the siting is not Mr Brough's decision.
Meanwhile, on one "urban drift" front where council should have been able to act decisively, nothing has been done. The front is in the Charles Creek reserve, a favourite illegal camping spot but also immediately in front of the home of longtime resident and outspoken senior citizen Gerry Baddock, in her eighties.
Mrs Baddock had asked for council to create some sort of barricade to prevent cars accessing the reserve.
Council was hoping that it was not their responsibility but the Northern Territory Government's; buck passing ensued until a compromise was reached, with each government agreeing pick up half the tab of $30,000 to do the works.
Mrs Baddock says the Territory Government came good with their $15,000 in July; there's still nothing from the council.
Apart from the continued disturbance to her sleep and peace of mind, Mrs Baddock says the count of trees destroyed by fires lit by illegal campers between the Telegraph Station turnoff and Basso Road since December 12 last year is 17.
Council's apparent unwillingness to shell out on this count, as on a number of others, has to be seen in the context of the at least $10.4m expenditure on the redevelopment of the Civic Centre, officially opened on July 1.
However fair or unfair (given that half the budget was borrowed and the loan was unlikely to be available to conduct operational matters) the public sees a council hamstrung by lack of funds - to, for instance, repair the basketball stadium or to pay for CCTV cameras in the CBD - while they've allocated to themselves relatively opulent and certainly over-sized facilities.
On top of this, some aspects of the redevelopment have been poorly managed:-
¥ council was forced to apologise to the community over the management of the furniture contract which effectively excluded local businesses;
¥ the innovative air-conditioning system, costing so far $1.2m, would be great if we were experiencing northern hemisphere December temperatures;
¥ the public toilets, always intended to be staffed, do not include a booth for the attendant who at present sits in the entry, open to the elements except for a security grille.
Council can take credit for recognising the need to do something about the devastating impact of alcohol, initiating the move to become a dry town.
However, as this is little more than a rebadging of the 2km law, widely disregarded and under-enforced, it remains to be seen what effect it will have when it comes into force.
Council opposed any other form of liquor restrictions as "anti-business".
Council can also take credit for trying to draw the Territory Government's attention to the needs of the town, not least in respect of law and order issues.
The relationship with the Territory Government, however, is poor. Not a council meeting goes by without a number of comments made that reflect a perception that the Territory Government doesn't listen, doesn't care, and above all doesn't want to spend the money.
This may seem surprising given Mayor Fran Kilgariff's Labor Party candidature in the last Territory elections.
Given that she didn't win, that move has been costly both for Ms Kilgariff and the town.
She is seen to be a creature of the Territory Government at a time when the town wants a fiercely independent voice.
Her comment to a NAIDOC forum that Alice Springs is set to become "an Indigenous town" in 10 to 15 years' time and no longer a town "where white people set the rules" showed her to be out of step with the community that council represents.
PROSPEROUS
There seems little doubt that Indigenous people will increasingly make up a greater proportion of the Alice Springs population: the emphasis needs to be on a shared, peaceful and prosperous future.
Articulating that vision and shifting the agenda from the present alarm and divisiveness is the big challenge for council in 2007.
They would be assisted by better decision-making processes that avoid knee-jerk responses. Ald Jane Clark has suggested one way to achieve this, which would be worth reconsidering.
They would also be assisted by strong working relationships with a forward-looking Indigenous leadership.
In 2006 the local native title organisation Lhere Artepe has demonstrated its desire to participate in community discussion at every level. CAAMA too, in reactivating the combined Aboriginal organisations meetings, has shown an awareness of the need for Indigenous leadership. Tangentyere Council and the Central Land Council, however, maintain a bunker mentality.
What a gift to the future of the town and the region if they could break that down.
CREATIVE PULSE BEATING IN ALICE . By KIERAN FINNANE.
In a year when our town's confidence in itself wavered its creative pulse continued, for the most part loud and strong.
First and foremost, Alice Springs is a hub for Australia's most famous art movement, the art of the central deserts, still vibrant as it heads towards four decades of expression through paint on canvas.
2006 has seen a lot of publicity as well as a senate committee inquiry into "carpetbagging", with its report and recommendations due in March 2007.
The well-meaning focus on this, including from prominent local players like Papunya Tula and Desart, is wrong-footed, tainting with victimhood the spectacular success of Aboriginal individuals and culture at a time when success has otherwise been hard to find.
A front-footed inquiry into how to support and strengthen the industry, taking an open-minded look at the way in which its present structures serve the artists and the audience for their work, would have been preferable.
Meanwhile, with both the Territory Government and the Alice Town Council allocating resources for public art, it is to be hoped that our town will soon be marked by a major public art work celebrating Indigenous creativity - long overdue.
It is also to be hoped that artists in all fields will be thinking of how to achieve collaborative work between Indigenous and non-Indigenous partners, bearing witness to all the complexities of our shared present, raising beacons to guide us towards a more happily shared future.
Red Dust Theatre has certainly declared this as its intent, and 2007 will see the production of Warren H. Williams' family entertainment, The Magic Coolamon, as its first cab off the rank.
Watch This Space and its coordinator Kieren Sanderson are behind a major arts project, titled Art, Land, Culture, scheduled for early 2007. This will see both a symposium (incubator) thrashing out ideas about things like collaborative practice, community cultural development, art and social change, storied landscape, placemaking and environmental based art practice, as well as the development and exhibition of work.
The Alice Desert Festival, after a low point in 06 (in part due to a very short run-up time for its general manager), has listened to feedback and is revamping itself for 07. Dates are set - September 14 to 23 - and a series of stand alone events produced by the festival begins on March 3 with a masked ball.
Hopefully the program proper will be stamped by work of depth coming out of the Centre.
There is definitely a deep vein of creative energy to draw from: 2006 saw a wonderful flourishing in wearable arts, music, film-making, writing. But a festival needs to act as more than an umbrella for these diverse threads: all-over artistic direction for a festival is indispensable.
The importance of creative endeavour to the future of our town should not be under-estimated as a minority interest.
Doubters should take note of the research, amongst others the University of Queensland Business School's report on Innovation in Rural Queesnland, sub-headed "Why some towns thrive, while others languish" (presented at the Desert Knowledge Symposium and reported on in the Alice News of Nov 9) .
The report found creative occupations and industries to be among the key indicators for thriving towns.
The most innovative town of the study "celebrates its creative artisticÊdimension in a very public way".
And the least innovative "made no mention of artistic or creative aspects ofÊtheir towns".
NUMBERS BRAWL IN TOURISM, BUT THE BOTTOM LINE IS WE'RE STILL WAITING FOR THE BIG BOOM . By ERWIN CHLANDA.
Our tourism managers, the lobby CATIA and the lavishly funded government commission now called Tourism NT, were shaken out of their complacency.
Operator Chris Chambers, using government figures, claimed the industry has been in decline for 20 years.
This has been especially the case where the smaller operators were involved, the kind of people who channel visitors' money into the town's broad economy.
PLAYERS
At the moment it seems the big players - airlines, big hotels and the government supported convention centre - are getting the lion's share.
As usual, CATIA and Tourism NT asserted all was fine.
Nevertheless, CATIA got a new chairman, Steve Rattray, who wasted no time putting the bite on the Alice Town Council for a special levy used for the town's - not the region's - promotion.
This raised the question why that is necessary, given that Tourism NT is swimming in money.
Its budget of $40m a year, looking after an industry with a population base of just 200,000, is so far ahead of the other states it makes your head spin.
There was no explanation why only six per cent of operators are taking part in the Brolgas, supported by the taxpayer to the tune of $100,000.
Statistics again proved that they can be used to prove or disprove anything at all.
But the bottom line remained that the tourism industry's 20 year graph is pretty flat, with a few predictable squiggles, not the sharply rising curve one would expect given The Centre's magnificent landscape, home to the world's oldest surviving culture.
Meanwhile Alderman Samih Habib has initiated talks with small airlines to get a service to Alice Springs other than Qantas which is coy about its fares. The Alice News did not get answers to specific questions about ticket costs since Virgin withdrew in 2005.
But there's plenty of anecdotal evidence that fares have gone up.