ALICE SPRINGS NEWS
April 30, 2009. This page contains all
reports and comment pieces in the current edition.
liquor litter charge. By KIERAN FINNANE.
“You don’t want my comment, you wouldn’t be able to print it!” said a
furious Diane Loechel, owner with husband Ray of the Gapview Hotel, as
she left Tuesday’s meeting about the Town Council’s liquor litter
charge, which disclosed the scale of the charge.
The Gapview Hotel and the Todd Tavern, together with the two
supermarket-associated bottleshops in the CBD, will attract a charge of
These four have the lion’s share (the Alice News understands, 70%) of
the take-away liquor market in Alice Springs.
The charge will actually be directed to the property-owners where
take-away liquor outlets are located, 12 in all.
The smaller outlets will attract charges of $7,500 each.
The money will offset the expense to council of cleaning up
liquor-related litter from public areas in the town.
Samih Habib, an alderman who as part-owner of the Milner Road shopping
centre is also affected by the charge, was also angry as he left the
meeting: “The courts will decide,” he said.
He said there are people on council who think that all businessmen are
“There are no millionaires in this town – they’ve all left,” he said.
Col Penley, manager for Power Mining, owners of the Coles Complex, said
it was “certainly not our view” that 12 property owners should
subsidise litter collection in town.
“The liquor outlets did not put the litter there, someone else did,” he
Mr Habib has not been involved in council’s recent debates and
decision-making on the charge because of his conflict of interest.
Ald Brendan Heenan, chair of council’s finance committee, was absent on
business on Monday when the vote was taken, but had let Mayor Ryan know
that the charge had his full support.
The remaining seven aldermen all voted to push ahead with the charge as
part of council’s draft business plan which was to be released
All residents, including of course the liquor retailers and
property-owners affected by the liquor litter charge, have until May 21
to respond to the plan.
Mayor Damien Ryan was confident that although opposition would be
encountered in some quarters, other quarters would appreciate council’s
action given that litter and cleanliness rate at the top of residents’
concerns about the town.
About possible legal action, Mayor Ryan said: “We’re working with
what’s available to us under the Local Government Act. If we go to
court, the Act goes to court.”
Ald Murray Stewart said: “A clean town is good for business and that
includes the liquor retail businesses.”
Ald Heenan acknowledged that some people were “uptight and upset” but
“we need to clean the town up”.
The charge will be imposed from the next financial year, which will
also see the start of council’s cash for containers scheme for an
initial 12 months.
This will cost council $465,000, with two people employed to run a
recycling collection station at council’s depot in Wilkinson Street,
open every Friday and Saturday, 7.30am to 3pm.
Council will be paying five cents per glass or can drink container,
limited to 500 at a time and only to Alice Springs residents.
The container deposit scheme in SA, which started in 1977, sees
approximately 540 million refundable containers sold in South Australia
every year, with approximately 420 million returned for refunds.
Is it a lesson in delaying
container deposit laws?
Container deposit legislation in the Territory? Don’t hold your breath
– or should we say, don’t worry, it’s not going to happen.
That seems to be the message from John Gaynor, Chief Minister Paul
Henderson’s senior adviser in Alice Springs, in an email to a liquor
The Alice News showed the communication to Mayor Damien Ryan and asked
him to comment.
He said the Federal and NT Governments have had over 30 years – ever
since container deposit legislation came into force in South Australia,
back in 1975 – to introduce a scheme in the Territory.
He says Alice Springs “can’t operate as a town with the quantity of
liquor litter we have”.
A previous trial by council of a cash for cans scheme over three months
took 339,000 cans out of the litter stream for recycling.
The scheme the council now hopes to get up and running will apply to
drink bottles as well as cans.
“We would hope the Territory Government does bring along a cash for
container scheme by 2011 but I would need to be convinced that they
will move quickly.
“In this document [Mr Gaynor’s email] I’m concerned to see so many
hurdles mentioned and don’t read any enthusiasm for a start date.
“Meanwhile we can’t sit back and wait.”
This is what Mr Gaynor, in well honed bureaucratese, has to say:–
There are some complexities to be resolved in a mandatory, Territory
wide container deposit scheme that don’t arise in the voluntary deposit
trials that have [been] undertaken over the year[s], for example:
• An appropriate model needs to be determined for the “materials
co-ordinator” who brokers the flow of containers and deposits and
handling fees between the manufacturers and collection depots.
This is a critical function of any legislated container deposit scheme
that is robust and has financial accountability. Options include
industry operated and independently operated. Legal issues such
as taxation are relevant.
• Further financial modelling is required to determine an appropriate
level of collection depots while maintaining financial viability of the
• Options for limiting the stockpiling of cans and bottles prior to
commencement of the scheme need to be determined – significant
stockpiling would have the potential to distort the financial operation
of the scheme in its early years.
• Negotiations need to occur with the beverage manufacturers on issues
such as how to transition the labelling requirements on containers.
• Further analysis and discussions need to occur to determine the role
that community stores might play as collection points in remote
communities that are distant from the more formalised collection
depots. All Territorians should have a reasonable opportunity of
All of the above require further legal, financial and project
management investigation and will involve analysing how other
jurisdictions (some international) have dealt with the issues.
The results will feed into the design of the legislation which in turn
frames the operational scheme.
Once the design features are settled there are a number of further
necessary steps before the scheme becomes operational, including:
• Legislation to establish the scheme needs to be written and passed in
the Legislative Assembly – the community will rightly expect
opportunity for some input;
• The materials co-ordinator needs to be established with the purpose
of brokering the deposits and handling fees between manufacturers and
• A systematic compliance, accounting and auditing regime of materials
and deposits needs to be developed to ensure the financial and legal
robustness of the scheme;
• The main collection depots need to be in place. This may involve an
expressions of interest process;
• A clear set of policies and standards for redeeming deposits needs to
be developed to guide operations of collection depots (covering issues
such as how many cans and bottles can be redeemed in one transaction).
• Collection depots will then need to be licensed to ensure that the
standards are adhered to;
• The materials co-ordinator will need to enter into financial
arrangements with collection depots;
• Industry needs to change its labels and enter into arrangements with
the materials co-ordinator; and
• A substantial community awareness program needs to be developed so
that Territorians understand what is happening, when the scheme becomes
operational and where they can go to redeem deposits.
Given that, 2011 is not an easy target – but if the scheme can be
established sooner, it will.
The proposed timeline is certainly consistent with international
experience - Hawaii for example took over two years to get their CDL
system up and running.
Why some will never get
elected. By KIERAN FINNANE.
The present method of counting votes in local government elections in
the Territory – known as the exhaustive preferential system – is
leading to domination of large groups in the new shires, while small
groups are left out in the cold, electorally speaking.
The issue is raised regularly after municipal elections in Alice
Springs, where eight members (formerly 10) are chosen from a single
ward and historically minority candidates with hefty primary votes have
not been successful. (Google ‘exhaustive’ in our web story archive.)
It has now come to the attention of an Australian National University
researcher, Dr Will Sanders, who is also involved in the Desert
Knowledge CRC’s Sustainable Desert Settlements project.
He was intrigued to observe the results in the multi-members wards of
the newly formed Central Desert and MacDonnell shires following the
inaugural elections last year.
How was it, he wondered, that in well-contested four member races
people with very small primary votes were getting elected into the
third and fourth positions?
He found the answer in the vote counting system.
It takes the method for a single member electorate – where a member
needs to get half the vote plus one – and applies it to a multi-member
In effect this produces repeated single-member elections within the
Each time a candidate is successful their ballots are re-distributed as
primary votes to the second preference choice on those ballots.
Thus voters for the most successful candidate are effectively able to
double dip and get their second choice up as well, so “fuelling large
Dr Sanders looked at the example of Central Desert Shire’s Southern
Tanami Ward, which takes in the settlements of Yuendumu (the largest),
Nyirripi and Willowra.
Candidates from Nyirripi and Willowra got the highest number of primary
votes, but ultimately the successful candidates were all from Yuendumu.
The first and second-placed candidates both got reasonably high primary
votes, but the third and fourth-placed were close to the bottom in the
They moved up the pack on the basis of being the second choice of
voters for the first and second place-getters.
Similarly, in Central Desert Shire’s Anmatjere Ward, the first and
second place getters came from Nturiya / Ti-Tree and Laramba and were
ultimately joined by candidates from Ti-Tree and Yuelamu.
While this looks like more of a spread, Dr Sanders, who has done
extensive work in the Anmatjere area over the years, points out that
the end result left the smaller communities of the eastern part of the
He is less familiar with groupings in other areas, but also looked at
the results in MacDonnell Shire’s Ljirapinta Ward, where the first
place-getter, with a reasonably high primary vote, was joined in second
place by a family member with a much lower primary vote.
In an alternative counting method, known as proportional
representation, the successful candidates’ ballots are taken out of the
race before the next round.
This basically says to those voters, you’ve got your candidate, now
let’s give others voters a chance.
And with proportional representation, instead of each candidate having
to achieve half the vote plus one, in a four-member race, for example,
they have to achieve a fifth of the vote plus one.
In a six-member race it would be a seventh of the vote plus one.
The mathematical rule is the same, which makes it possible to have a
mix of single and mutli-member electorates or wards within the one
This type of counting leads to a broader spread of representation
across an electorate, with minority groups standing a much better
chance of getting up a candidate.
Dr Sanders is talking to the Territory Government about a change in
counting methods in local government elections but he points out that
the shires themselves can take action.
Instead of dividing the shires into multi-member wards they could
divide them into multiple single-member wards, or smaller multi-member
wards, to give smaller groups within the shire a better chance of
It was up to the shires how they divided up their electorate. Each was
to have a shire council of 12 members and most chose to have four
But one shire, Victoria-Daly, chose to have eight wards – six
single member wards, plus one two-member ward and one four-member ward
(Wadeye), roughly reflecting population.
This shire was thus more prescriptive than the others, says Dr Sanders,
about ensuring representation for smaller groups.
Using the exhaustive preferential system “repeats a historic mistake”,
says Dr Sanders. It was used for Australian Senate elections from 1919
to 1946, yielding wildly swinging majorities – “at times there were
only three Opposition senators”.
When the counting system changed, the Senate become more representative
and thus more legitimate in the eyes of the people.
Exhaustive preferential counting was also abandoned in Victorian local
government elections after their amalgamation reforms in the ‘nineties,
because it was seen to be having the unintended consequence of large
This “winner takes all majoritarianism” is not good where there’s
social diversity, says Dr Sanders.
Shire CEO pulls pin. By ERWIN
The MacDonnell Shire is less than a year old yet its CEO, Wayne Wright,
has resigned and will finish up tomorrow.
He says personal and family matters are the reason, and he will be
moving to Darwin.
He says the start of the shire was “difficult” but the staff are
“fantastic, as good as anyone could hope to work with”.
Mr Wright says he has the “utmost respect” for the councillors who he
says will be “moving the MacDonnell Shire forward.
“Very good things will be happening.”
Mr Wright has previously worked in WA and Victoria and was an engineer
with state government owned SA Water for 23 years.
Mr Wright says local government in the NT is a “fantastic industry” and
he recommends it as a career.
Slump slows down re-think of
how to better run Centre. By KIERAN FINNANE.
The uncertain economic climate is slowing down progress for the
remoteFocus project, launched last year in an effort to get a re-think
on how government decisions affecting remote Australia are made.
“There’s a mentality mismatch,” says John Huigen, CEO of Desert
Knowledge Australia, which facilitated the project.
“Decision-making takes place thousands of kilometres away by people who
live in a completely different context.
“There’s an understandable tendency in government to have
one-size-fits-all policies but this doesn’t necessarily work well for
the 4.5% of the population living in remote areas.
“People from the bush suffer from the tyranny of democracy and this can
produce unhelpful dynamics, a feeling of being forgotten, even
“remoteFocus is not about blaming anyone and it is entirely
unpolitical, but we do want to develop some propositions around a new
way for remote Australia to be administered and governed.”
The group’s initial “prospectus”, which outlined the case for change,
was developed with funding from BHP, Rio Tinto and the WA Local
Mr Huigen says the mining companies were interested in the project
because they are often relied upon to solve gaps in service delivery in
remote areas, which would otherwise be the responsibility of
However with the economic downturn they, together with most companies,
are battening down the hatches. Last week the MacDonnell Shire in
the NT handed over $50,000 to remoteFocus.
In a press release Shire President Raymond Kiernan said: “People living
in remote Australia, like our residents in the MacDonnell Shire
Council, face daily challenges that are often not understood or
considered by government when most Australians live in urban coastal
“By supporting Desert Knowledge’s remoteFOCUS project our Shire Council
will be part of investigating and shaping long term, strategic changes
in the way all levels of government approach governing remote
But so far, that $50,000 is all that’s in the remoteFocus coffers.
The funds are required to take the next step, which is to assemble a
wide range of people, with strong interest and background in remote
Australia, to develop a set of propositions about the kind of
governance changes needed.
Following this the project wants to take these propositions to the
people for testing and refining.
How extensively it can do this will depend on the amount of money they
And this, at the present time, is proving difficult.
Could town camps leases be
With Tangentyere Council again refusing to come to an agreement with
the Federal Government over long-term leases for housing blocks on town
camps, should the Territory Government consider resumption of the
NT Indigenous Affairs Minister Alison Anderson says she is still hoping
that Federal Minister Jenny Macklin can achieve a negotiated solution
with Tangentyere Council on D-day, May 4.
She says the drawn-out negotiations can’t be allowed to continue and is
hoping that the Tangentyere Executive will bear in mind the aims of
what the Federal Government is trying to do: providing stable, secure
accommodation and improved infrastructure for the men, women and
children of the town camps.
“And I’m hoping too that soon we can change the name from ‘town camp’
She says a question raised by Tangentyere was that the $50m that is on
the table won’t go very far once it’s divvied up between all the camps.
However, she says Ms Macklin made it clear that if a lease agreement is
signed there’s a “high likelihood” of more money.
An informed source, who spoked to the Alice News on the understanding
that he would not be named, says the lease issue is a red herring.
The leases, which are either Crown leases or Special Purpose leases in
perpetuity could be resumed under certain conditions – such as
unapproved use or littering.
But, says the source, as it is likely that those conditions would be
addressed by the leaseholders, thus removing the possibility of
resumption, that course of action would be futile.
And he points out that although the land on which public housing is
built elsewhere in the Territory is government- controlled, this in
itself does not resolve the issues around proper care and maintenance
of the housing.
An alternative course of action would be to convert the leases to
freehold, allowing some residents to purchase their own home and
presumably care for it in such a way that it becomes a “shining
example” for their neighbours.
Bureaucrats spend $2.3m to
oversee $5.7m in programs. By KIERAN FINNANE.
The bad news is that there’s no more money – the Territory’s arts
budget will stay stable at $8.5m – but the good news is that Arts
Minister Alison Anderson is determined to get more of that money into
the hands of artists and more fairly spread across the Territory.
That means tackling the big ones: the cost of a burgeoning arts
bureaucracy compared to the funding of projects and programs; and the
highly centralised structure of key arts organisations, each with a
supposed Territory-wide charter.
“Cultural and recreational services”, to which the arts are a key
contributor, according to the Alice Springs Economic Profile,
contribute over $25m a year to the local economy, just under two per
cent of the gross regional product.
Speaking to the Alice News before last week’s arts forum, “Are We Arts
Wise?” Ms Anderson asked with characteristic frankness: “How can we
have a $2m bureaucracy administering $5m worth of programs?”
Unfortunately she could not attend the forum, but her forthright chief
of staff, Mathew Fagan, added to the picture: $2.3m goes into ArtsNT,
while $5.7m goes to arts organisations and individual practitioners.
However, as he pointed out, there is also an administrative component
in the latter figure, with every organisation and grant recipient
obviously engaged in administrative processes of their own.
So the amount of money that actually goes into making art and taking it
to the people is significantly less, though Mr Fagan couldn’t say by
He told the forum that it has become clear that the Territory
Government to date has not had a clear set of strategic priorities for
arts funding and that Ms Anderson wants to change that.
The point of the forum was the get some guidance from artists, arts
workers and interested others about what these priorities should be.
While Ms Anderson has some ideas, she doesn’t want to impose them
without consultation, he said.
However, she is committed to a more even spread of arts funding and
activity across the Territory.
At present intensity of activity depends very much on who is good at
writing submissions and where they are located or who they have
A more equitable spread would not be confined to addressing an
imbalance between Darwin and Alice.
Getting more activity into rural and remote areas will be not only
“fair”, he said, but unsurprising as a priority from a Minister who
herself comes from a remote community.
As well, Ms Anderson had earlier told the News that some arts
practitioners are clearly missing out relative to others, naming
particularly film-makers, writers and performing artists.
Mr Fagan was asked whether funding is skewed to peak bodies.
“Yes”, he answered.
He later added that arts organisations, like many government
departments, operate “in silos”, each with an outreach program.
This results in activity outside the major centres being spread very
thinly. The facilitator asked the meeting to consider whether there
should be another model.
Not an easy question to answer on the hop and no clear response was
A question went back: was the forum discussion leading into the
development of a Territory arts policy, in which case at least a year
would be needed as well as a strong document to work from.
Mr Fagan later said that policy would be developed alongside reforms.
He said Ms Anderson wanted to see change quickly and wouldn’t be
prepared to wait 18 months while a policy was being worked up.
He told the meeting that she is a “hands on” Minister, not a “rubber
stamper”, that she drives policy, that she wants to take her reform
program to Cabinet in June – which actually does not give much time for
Another change Ms Anderson wants to see is an end to the stop-start
nature of much of the funding for arts activities, he said.
She wants smaller centres and regions to have long-term funding
certainty, he said.
And Ms Anderson told the News that a lot of time and effort is wasted
with 12 month funding cycles.
She said a typical pattern is that three months is spent on preparing
funding submissions, followed by a three month wait for an answer.
If successful there’s a three month period of activity before a three
month acquittal phase.
She wants to put a stop to that.
The implication of all this, given that the bucket of money will remain
the same, is that there will be winners and losers, but without
detailed comparative analysis of how much money is spent on what and
where, it is hard to predict where the axe will fall.
And without this analysis it was likewise hard for the strong
contingent of local artists and arts workers who attended the forum to
offer informed views on what should be prioritised.
For a meeting like this to be productive better groundwork needs to be
done in advance.
At a glance it would seem, especially since the amalgamation of RedHOT
Arts and the Alice Desert Festival into a single organisation, there’s
scarcely any fat to trim in the Centre.
Indeed those attending the forum were quick to point to the substantial
deficits, particularly in arts infrastructure in Alice Springs: the
lack of a performance venue other than pubs and clubs for local
musicians and the complete lack of a rehearsal venue for them; the lack
of a permanent outdoor performance space; the lack, especially since
the Central Australian Art Society shed was destroyed by fire, of a
studio space for visual artists.
Many of these needs could be catered for by a Central Australian school
of art, it was suggested. It could not only increase local opportunity
but draw people here from interstate and overseas.
There was some discussion about continuity of funding not only for
organisations but for projects, such as the annual Bush Bands Bash.
There was strong support for other government departments – health,
education, environment, infrastructure – to make arts activity and
funding part of their business.
A “percent for art” scheme, whereby all major infrastructure projects
allocate a percentage of their budgets to commissioning art integral to
the project, would be one way to address this.
(The Town Council to their credit has such a scheme and the new aquatic
centre will be enhanced by several works of art as a result.)
A forum bringing together bureaucrats from government departments and
artists could be helpful in this regard, to get past artists being
“treated as an irritant”.
Lobbying for a significant arts program in the amalgamated high schools
(ASHS and Anzac Hill) was urged.
Some income security for artists was raised as an issue, with pointed
reference to the contrasting position of some arts administrators:
“You don’t want to see yet another administration person on $80,000 a
year while you’re on $10,000.”
Several comments were made around the perception of arts activities as
elitist, not for the “common person”, requiring high level skills and
as a result not attracting the kind of government support that sports
do (especially in terms of infrastructure), and not having the same
presence in community consciousness as sports do.
There were comments around assessment of arts grant applications and
the importance of judging them on the basis of their pursuit of
excellence and innovation.
Mr Fagan commented on “a real tension” between the pursuit of
excellence and the push for greater accessibility and a more “common”
More celebrations of the arts through festivals and awards would be a
way of raising awareness of the arts and rewarding excellence, it was
The forum did not hear anything specific on the future of the NT Film
To the Alice News Ms Anderson described the budget of the Film Office
as “absolutely nothing” and said it should not remain in “the arts
Some kind of partnership arrangement with the Department of Business
could offer a solution.
A similar forum will be held soon in Darwin, and the Territory’s 20
major Aboriginal communities will also be consulted over the next two
months, said Mr Fagan.
There were calls for greater investment in Indigenous arts workers and
for training to be linked to job certainty, but otherwise the forum
heard little about the Indigenous art sector.
Ms Anderson told the News that there will be discussion around whether
Indigenous arts will continue to be treated in separate categories by
Feral dogs maul stud calf in
the town area.
Rod Cramer from Temple Bar Station, a small pastoral lease within the
Alice municipality, called on the Town Council this week to start legal
dog baiting in the more remote parts of the municipality.
This followed the mauling death on Monday of a second stud calf
(pictured) at the station in less than two weeks.
The animal was attacked by a pack of feral dogs – not dingos, said Mr
He told council that the calf had had both its ears torn off before it
The unfortunate animal’s death was the fourth or fifth at Temple Bar
this year, representing a “substantial economic loss” and creating
“extensive trauma for us and the herd”.
Mr Cramer said baiting is the only way to deal with the problem.
However, although the NT Government has approved the use of “Doggone “
dry baits (in biscuit form) in the NT, he said Parks and Wildlife are
the only legal suppliers of the baits and they don’t allow use of them
in municipal areas.
Mr Cramer argued that council could become authorised to handle baits
within the municipality.
Council’s Director of Corporate and Community Services, Craig
Catchlove, says council could possibly obtain permission to bait but
has previously decided against it principally because of the potential
for the bait “to fall into the wrong hands” (human or animal), but also
because it is a “nasty way” for an animal to die.
The issue will be revisited and a report prepared for council’s meeting
Meanwhile, council rangers will “up the ante” with trapping and
shooting in the Temple Bar area, but, says Mr Catchlove, as Mr Cramer
is already doing these things himself, how much more can be achieved is
Writers to cook up word storm.
A late addition to the already impressive Eye of the Storm writers’
festival line-up is Najaf Mazari, a master rugmaker who fled
Afghanistan in 2001 and ended up in Woomera Detention Centre.
The story of his youth in a northern Afghan village, during a time of
civil war, and later his capture by the Taliban and flight on a small
boat to Australia, is told in The Rugmaker of Mazar-e-Sharif,
co-authored by Mazari and biographer Robert Hillman.
At Eye of the Storm, which kicks off tomorrow, Mazari will take part in
a panel titled Place Matters (replacing Beck Cole).
Together with authors Linda Jaivin, Michael Watts and Arnold Zable
he’ll discuss the impact of place on his writing (Sunday 2.45pm).
He’ll also be a guest at the special event, 1001 Nights, again with
Zable and Jaivin and joined by Centralians Kenny Laughton and Jo
Dutton. This is billed as a night under the stars (at the Alice Springs
Resort) with a Middle Eastern feast and “Scheherazade tales of love and
heartbreak from around the globe” (Saturday, 8-10pm).
The panels and special events of the festival are a way for “a
conversation to take place between Central Australian writers and
writers from elsewhere”, says festival director Sandra Thibodeaux.
In putting the program together she sought to “celebrate writing
specifically birthed in the Central Australian landscape, cultures and
The themes of the panels and events came in part from the writers but
were also shaped by a desire “to highlight what is special about the
Centre”, says Thibodeaux.
There’ll be several book launches: Jennifer Mills’ novel The Diamond
Anchor (Monday, 4.30); two poetry collections – little bit long time by
Ali Cobby Eckermann, and Awake During Anaesthetic by Kimberley Mann
(Saturday, 4,30); and the new anthology of writing from the Centre,
Fishtails in the Dust, published by Ptilotus Press (Friday, 7pm).
An exhibition of visual artists’ responses to selected writing from
Fishtails will show at Watch This Space on Saturday, 6pm, and run until
Authors contributing to IAD Press’ inaugural NT Indigenous anthology
will be giving a preview of the publication (Sunday, 11.45am.)
Acclaimed Australian author Kate Grenville features heavily in the
program. In particular the panel, 222 Years in the Telling, in which
she’ll explore, together with others, contact between Indigenous and
non-Indigenous Australians, should be a crowd puller. (Saturday,
Popular crime writer, Shane Maloney, in conversation with TV host
Jennifer Byrne will close the festival on Monday night, at an event
called Stiff, the title of Maloney’s first Murray Whelan novel. That
promises plenty of laughs from ºone of the country’s funniest
authors, whose novels are set in the murky world of politics. (5.30-8pm
For full program details go to: www.ntwriters.com.au
Musical overload in the Wide
Open Spaces. By POP VULTURE.
Tomorrow, Friday, the first darling bud of May, sees the Wide Open
Spaces music and cultural festival begin at the picturesque Ross River
resort, 85 kilometres east of town.
Imagine three days out of town, three days with an overload of things
to do and see, three days of music with an emphasis on what some people
born on the cusp of generation x and y are moving to.
Elefant Traks’ Urthboy will be there. One of this country’s best known
MCs, his lyrical sense has placed him on the cutting edge of the
Australian Hip Hop scene (Elefant Traks is an Australian Hip Hop record
label). Although currently working on a solo release, Urthboy is better
known for his collective work with the The Herd.
Another act will be Spoonbill. I have been a fan of this eclectic
mixing fiend for a little over a year now, when a friend gave me copies
of two of his releases, “Nestegg” and “Megafauna”, released on Omlette
records of Melbourne.
I’ve saved hearing the music from his latest instalment, “Zoomorphic”
(released only last month) until the festival’s debut.
He plays with a juxtaposition of sounds edged with comedy, involving
instruments, dialogues, monologues, and what sometimes appear to be
Seeing this performed live will for me be one of the highlights of the
festival, worth the daily entrance fee alone.
Now to Melbourne’s Mista Savona. Their music is a lacing of reggae,
stylee and heavyweight Jamaican dancehall. A lot of the rhythms and
beats pre-written (a hallmark of these genres) but Mista Savona adds a
new and “modernesque” flavour to the old recipe. Newcomers will find it
an easy music to move to.
A veritable bonfire of music and energy, and another jewel in the crown
of Friday evening, is Combat Wombat, a Melbourne-based contingent of
MCs and DJs.
They last made the trek to Alice about three years ago and some members
still sway back and forth from here, coordinating Hip Hop workshops in
different Indigenous communities.
Combat Wombat combine lyrics of a strong political nature with
intelligent humour, and watching them perform can be an enlightening
Charming tree hugger champions
environment. By BEVERLEY JOHNSON.
Tree hugging, environment loving, Liana Werner-Gray has spent time
recently educating local students on how to reduce their carbon
footprint and help take better care of the world.
Miss Werner-Gray, passionate about being green, has plans to visit
schools throughout Australia. Having grown up in the Territory there
was no better place to start than Gillen Primary School, where she was
once a pupil.
“If we do not teach and encourage todays youth to take more action
towards caring for the environment, then there will be nothing left to
enjoy in the future,” says Miss Werner-Gray.
During morning assembly she had pupils taking part in a game she has
made up that helps them understand how everyday activities can effect
the carbon footprint.
There are hundreds of ways you can reduce your carbon footprint, she
Examples that young people are easily capable of include planting a
tree, eating locally grown produce and unplugging their mobile phone
charger when it’s not in use.
Principal David Glyde discovered his carbon footprint was quite high.
So he’s decided to start riding his bike more and not use so many
Said Mr Glide, “It is tremendous what Liana is doing. To see a previous
pupil spreading awareness on such an important and topical issue is
Students Tianne Rothwell and Claire Thomas said they really enjoyed the
game and Miss Werner-Gray has helped them to learn more about how to
stop polluting in the world.
Having created a website (www.iloveearth.com.au), Miss Werner-Gray
approached a number of businesses who have donated prizes for her
inspiring competition, “I love the earth”.
Anyone between the ages of five and 18 can enter a photo, video,
painting, drawing, story, poem, or song that demonstrates how they are
reducing their carbon footprint.
The competition closes on October 1.
“We need to inspire people to care for the environment.
“It sounds corny but there are not enough people leading the world who
are tree huggers,” says Miss Werner-Gray.
Twenty years ago Miss Werner-Gray’s mother rallied in Alice Springs for
a local recycling centre, an issue that hasn’t gone away.
“I have definitely followed in the footsteps of my mother,” she says.
“Alice Springs is where I spent a lot of my youth. It is a place that
has impacted my life. It is a place that I will never forget.”
Once the face of Yamba’s playtime princess, Miss Werner-Gray went on to
star in the television show “I’m a celebrity, get me out of here”. She
is a now a nominee for the 2009 Miss Earth Australia competition, a
green initiative that takes place in Sydney this September.
LETTERS: Tourist says town is
Sir,– We visited your beautiful part of the world over Easter and had a
wonderful time driving around all the spectacular places.
One thing, though, was a shock not only to us, but to many other
visitors we came in contact with: the filth, broken bottles,
rubbish everywhere ... and the smelly people/groups associated with
Coming from Cairns, where this problem has been vigorously addressed,
we would suggest that you do something serious about this sorry
We even saw an Indigenous man defecate in broad view of passing people
– behind the building where the Information Centre is! The comment by
passing tourists was unprintable!
Suggestion: why not withhold the taxpayer funded handouts to these
people until they clean up their mess! Millions of $$ are wasted in
handouts, and nothing is being achieved.
Give them a big bag, a shovel and send them into the Todd River and the
parks where they congregate to pick up their filth, broken bottles
and so on, and then pay them after they have done the work – not
As a local nurse said: “We have to clean up after them, they take
this for granted and we are not allowed to say anything.”
Dr. Veronica Griffin,
Sir,– The insightful piece of writing by Tom Dutton (Alice News, April
23), concerning the football team from the community of Kintore, was a
He provided a splendid picture of just how much the adventurous 530km
trip into Alice for the annual Easter Lightning Football Carnival meant
to the combatants from Kintore. The footy carnival, which attracted 22
teams from communities spread far and wide in the Territory, as well as
from the Pitlands of SA and a team from over the border in WA,
does mean a hell of a lot to the competing communities and Tom brought
that aspect out so well in his article featuring the Kintore Hawks.
The strict rules imposed by the community leaders attached to the footy
team, as told by Tom regarding players’ eligibility for the trip,
emphasized the importance attached to the representation of the
Tom’s last paragraph, where he quotes the feelings of the players and
they tell him that “they had the best weekend of their lives”, is in
one way a tad sad but also a transparent telling of what can inspire
people on remote communities.
Tom’s piece also is a healthy reminder of the heavy commitment of
travel of those communities such as Papunya / Haasts Bluff, Yuendumu,
Mt. Allan / Laramba and Hermannsburg mob who compete in the Central
Australian footy competition in Alice each week.
It is a tribute that should be more widely recognized. They, and
Lytentye Apurte mob, have enriched the competition in no small way.
Graham Tjilpi Buckley
not be hunted
Sir,– Thank you for the opportunity to address the issue of safari
hunting of camels in Central Australia.
People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA) opposes all hunting
because of the suffering that it causes animals. Blasting away at
animals in the Outback is neither sporting nor ‘conservation’.
Hunters often argue that they are ‘managing’ wildlife, yet hunting
creates conditions that favor accelerated reproduction: the abrupt
population decline that it causes leads to less competition for food
among survivors and ultimately, a higher birth rate, thus leading once
more to the very problems that hunters claim to solve.
Organizers of camel hunts will not primarily be interested in humanely
controlling camel populations, but rather in ensuring that there is an
endless supply of camels for their clients to harass and kill.
And don’t forget that hunted animals are never killed in ways that do
not cause suffering, especially when a hunting outfit is run for profit
or the experience is meant to be ‘fun’.
If our real concern is camel populations, then we should take steps to
reduce animals’ fertility. But no matter what we do, it must be humane.
Hunting does not fit the bill.
Australian Campaigns Coordinator
People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals
P & W price hike
Sir,– There is a petition running on the link below, regarding the
Power and Water price increases.
A lot of people are not happy with the price hike and the way the
government has handled the maintenance of our ageing utilities.
It is not just the increases that are the problem, but it is the
flow-on effect it will have on everything else as well.
There are also some very interesting things in the P&W 2008 annual
report, such as profit, $57.5m; bank balance, $89.3m; director’s
remuneration up 38%. No mention of need for price hike.
This petition is a way the people can voice their opinion. The
site has only been running for just on a week and there are already
over 1000 signatures.
Sir,– Four influential Northern Territory community groups are calling
on the Henderson Government to ensure that vulnerable Territorians were
not plunged into poverty by excessive increases in the cost of power
Concessions should be extended to all holders of health-care cards, so
that utility price increases do not push low income earners further
The Northern Territory Council of Social Service (NTCOSS) joined with
housing peak NT Shelter, seniors lobby group the Council on the Ageing,
and carers organisation Carers NT, to request that government
reconsider the proposed increases.
The Treasurer has indicated that power costs will increase by 18% on
July 1 this year, and by a further 5% the following year. Water costs
will also increase by 20% in each of the next three years.
NTCOSS applauds an indication from the Treasurer that the increased
costs will not be passed on to pensioners and carers.
However, the greatest impact will be felt by people on other benefits
such as Newstart Allowance and Youth Allowance, who are not entitled to
Extending concessions to all holders of health-care cards will provide
a measure of protection for Territorians who are most at risk.
These price hikes will also place further pressure on the exorbitant
cost of rental accommodation in Darwin, already the most expensive in
Government has a responsibility to assist disadvantaged Territorians on
low incomes especially as they prepare to weather the worst of the
global economic storm.
Wendy Morton, Executive Director, NTCOSS
Toni Vine-Bromley, Executive Director, NT Shelter
Sir,– The Henderson Government’s sharp increase in public housing rents
will push many Territory pensioners below the breadline.
A $20 increase on virtually all public housing tenancies will see some
residents rent jump by more than 17%.
The rent price hikes are sky high compared with increases in pensions.
Not satisfied with creating the highest private rents in the country
now the Henderson Government is putting the squeeze on residents in
public housing to cover the mismanagement of its budget.
Coming just weeks after a 25% increase in the price of electricity,
this rental price hike is particularly hypocritical
When private landlords increase rents by large amounts the Henderson
Government makes sympathetic noises.
When the Government turns into a rent gouging landlord the Chief
Minister is silent.
By allowing a 17% increase in the price of public housing has the
private rental market the green light to price gouge.
Leader of the Opposition
Retirees fight back
Sir,– The issue of Retirement Incomes is on top of the list for Seniors
in the Northern Territory as the Federal Government enters the final
weeks of refining the Federal Budget, due to come down in May.
The commitment of the Federal Government to sustainable Retirement
Income policy is very welcome indeed, as well as the promised relief
for the most vulnerable.
National Seniors Australia emphasises that at a time when retirement
incomes are under pressure it is unwise to target those people who have
been able to partially or fully fund their own retirement.
We are disturbed that a consistent theme in the debate and commentary
is that self funded retirees are all very wealthy and should not have
access to various Government support programs and entitlements.
Indeed some of the commentary is almost ideological and critical of
self funded retirees for being able to contribute to their own
The Northern Territory Policy Group of NSA has been active in promoting
a range of issues of concern to Senior Territorians.
We encourage all seniors to contact their Federal Parliamentary members
and lobby for their future particularly in relation to the impact of
the current economic outlook on Older Australians and the need for a
sustainable Retirement Income Policy.
Chair, NT Policy Group,National Seniors Australia
Free transport welcome
Sir,– NTCOSS applauds Transport Minister Gerry McCarthy’s recent
proposal for free public transport for all Territorians.
This action would encourage greater community involvement, and bring
substantial environmental benefit by reducing the number of cars on the
road and the associated pollution.
However, more bus routes and greater frequency of services are needed
for the system to be fully effective.
The lack of availability of public and community transport forces low
income people to rely on other more expensive forms of transport, such
as taxis and minibuses, to meet their everyday needs.
It can be particularly hard for mothers and their babies to get into
town for shopping and accessing services, when they do not have access
to public transport.
People miss out on public transport in the larger centres in the NT
because there are no bus routes close to their homes.
Some town camp residents in Alice Springs are more than two kilometres
from a public bus stop. In regional towns like Tennant Creek and
Katherine there are no public bus services at all.
Next month’s NT Budget presents an enormous opportunity for the
Government to make public transport more affordable and accessible.
Central Australian Policy Officer, NTCOSS
Sir,- There’s a troubling silence coming out of the Treasurer’s
Parliament House office just a week out from Delia Lawrie’s second
Commonwealth and other Territory revenues have dried up, so too has
Labor’s penchant for self promotion and self congratulation.
Normally by this time, the Government is sending out multiple press
releases about what is up-coming in the budget. We’ve seen a couple of
releases but big ticket announcements – like plans to lower pay-roll
tax or increase the pay-roll tax threshold – have been conspicuous by
In addition, I was particularly looking forward to reading the
Treasurer’s media release summarising Access Economics’ March Quarter
The Henderson Government had nobody but itself to blame for its
We all know that there are budget pressures on this Government caused
substantially by its squandering of $1.2billion of unexpected
Commonwealth revenue over the past seven years.
The Government has assiduously avoided warnings from many parties –
including its own Treasury – about the fickle nature of the GST cash
Because of this failure to plan we’re heading for a budget deficit and
a $200million black hole over the next 14 months.
In the interests of open and transparent governance, it’s time for
Delia Lawrie to say from where Labor’s going to raise taxes and charges
next financial year in addition to the Territory Housing rental
increases and power price hikes we’ve seen so far.
Sir,– IAD Management Committee has called another Special
General Meeting to be held on May 28. This meeting is requested by
17 IAD Members.
This is the second such request recently received from the same group
The first request dated February 4, 2009 resulted in an SGM being
convened under the Constitution on March 20.
That SGM was closed at 11.38am (having started at 11.18am) after
members of the requesting group were removed from the meeting for
The cost of holding that meeting was considerable; in excess of
$8000. The costs were paid from Institute funds.
The cost of repeated requests for SGMs is putting enormous strain on
the financial and other resources of the Institute and is a harmful
distraction from the work of the Institute.
The purpose of the second SGM to be held 28 May is
primarily to: “approve a members’ motion to remove from the current
Management Committee the current Chairperson, Deputy Chairperson,
Secretary, Public Officer and other Management Committee members, under
clause 30 of the IAD Constitution.”
There is currently no “members’ motion” before the IAD in these terms
or any other similar motion.
This means that the stated purpose calling for the SGM is no purpose at
all and is a nonsense. Therefore the Management Committee must
avoid incurring the expense of calling an SGM for a purpose that will
inevitably fail and create disorder.
This group has been asked to revisit their request, reformulate
its purpose, and then resubmit the request with the required number of
signatures (in accordance with clause 44 of the Constitution) and this
will then be actioned.
The requesting group have failed to do this.
The work of the Institute cannot be performed diligently and thoroughly
while this agenda is pursued by this disruptive group of
The current Management Committee has only been in place for three
months. It has only just had time to find its feet.
To suggest that it has done anything wrong in that time lacks logic and
smacks of ambition driven by self-interest.
The disruptive group led by Neville Perkins has no authority from
IAD, Neville Perkins has no authority to make statements on
behalf of IAD or to use IAD letterhead or IAD logo.
The current IAD Management Committee has always and will continue to
demonstrate accountability, appropriate transparency and respect
of its Members.
On Thursday 9 April 2009 a morning tea was held.
All IAD Members were invited.
Current Management Committee openly responded to many and all questions
from Members and a large number of Members left the Morning Tea assured
and with full confidence in the current Management Committee.
It was noted NOT one of the disruptive group who have called these SGMs
Institute for Aboriginal Development
Sir,– In addition to Coal Seam Gas seismic exploration and drilling, an
extensive oil and gas focused 2D seismic program is planned to be
mounted near Alice Springs later this year or early next year following
new results by Central Petroleum Limited which continue to point to the
region’s untapped hydrocarbon potential.
Analysis of the company’s recent drilling program in an area about 340
kilometres southeast of the Alice had concluded there were at least two
active petroleum systems in the Pedirka Basin.
Of particular interest is the substantial residual oil staining evident
in the Eromanga sequence within the Blamore-1 and Simpson-1 wells
drilled by the company in the Simpson Desert.
Staining was evident over 31 metres in Blamore-1 and over 17 metres in
While commercial oil was not encountered in either well, the residual
oil columns in each are consistent with our pre-drill models predicting
oil charge into the area from the Madigan Trough.
The results have increased our confidence as the likelihood of local
indigenous sourcing from oil shales, updip spillage and robust dip
closures in this part of the desert and we have therefore scheduled a
detailed seismic program to help identify enhanced drill targets for
The company believes the target area had potential Undiscovered Oil
Initially in Place (UOIIP) of around six billion barrels.
Any future exploration programme in the area is subject to the approval
of Joint Venture Partners, Petroleum Exploration Australia (PXA).
It is anticipated that a meeting will be held late in June 2009 to
consider the program proposed.
Central Petroleum Limited
Huge nurse turnover
Sir,– Recruiting more nurses to the Northern Territory is only half the
equation when it comes to ensuring properly staffed hospitals.
Retention is as important as recruitment but the new Health Minister,
Kon Vataskalis, has nothing to say about how he will staunch the 34%
turnover of Territory nurses each year, which places enormous strain on
the operation of Territory hospitals.
It costs more than $10,000 to put a new nurse on a ward. In a workforce
of 1900 that means $6.5 million will bleed from the health budget for
recruitment costs alone.
It’s impossible for a nursing workforce experiencing an extremely high
level of transience to provide a level of care comparable to that of a
Shadow Minister for Health
ADAM'S APPLE: Don’t give hate
When I was a child, my best friend was a boy named Matthew
Never let it be said that he and George Clooney could be mistaken for
Matthew, it is fair to say, looked like the love child of Bill Gates
and Woody Allen. All glasses and a mop of side-parted hair.
For a time in my youth Matthew and I were inseparable. We did
everything young boys do together. We got up to mischief together, we
rode our bikes together, we generally fell into 11-year-old love with
the same girl.
Unlike Alice Springs, my home town didn’t have many Americans. There
was a smattering, but there was a smattering of every culture so no one
nationality really stuck out. Matthew was born in Iowa, in the same
town as Radar O’Reilly from M*A*S*H.
Here the American population makes up a substantial part of the
community in every sense of the word.
They contribute not only to our population and our economy but also to
the culture of the place.
To the uninitiated, the idea that Americans are a significant part of
the Alice Springs community might seem a little strange. We are after
all the most Australian of towns, the heart of Australia as we all love
But if we think about it, Americans have a place in all of our
societies. From remote communities with their American-designed
electric guitars played in bush bands to the centre of urban culture
with hip-hop, America is everywhere.
I have no problem with that. I know there is a section of the national
community reluctant to allow American culture into Australia and which
mourns in earnest the death of the ‘cobber’, ‘she’ll be right’, fair
But the Australian culture has never been stagnant, constant and
unflinching. That, in my mind, is one of the great beauties of the
place. A nation full of people from every nation. A culture adaptable,
fluid and vibrant.
Australia has the rare ability to pick and choose what it likes and
what it does not.
One of the true pleasures of growing up in Australia is the ability to
immerse yourself for a spell in the cultures of the entire globe, from
Albania to Zimbabwe, without having to be defined by it.
Since the first black fella crossed the Indonesian land bridge all
those years ago, Australia has been a place where adaptation has been
the only key to defining the culture.
From Halal butchers to Brazilian waxes, we have embraced all the bits
of cultures we have liked.
And on the whole we’ve rejected the bits we don’t fancy. While Indian
immigrants were welcomed into society, the old caste system was not.
While welcoming members of the Muslim faith, we reject the more
fundamentalist of their populations.
American culture is no different. Without America there would be no
blues, no Hollywood, no Coca-Cola. Welcome to Australia, America!
But as there are parts of every culture we reject, there is a part of
America to which we should say a big ‘no, thank you.’
There are at present 926 hate groups operating in the United States.
From the regular run of the mill Klansmen through to the more obscure
anti-gay, anti-Jewish and anti-liberal co-operatives. Like all hate
groups all over the world they blame a small yet significant group of
society for all the perceived ills of the world.
Venomous and entirely victim-based, they preach their poison from the
pulpit, in the plaza and on the computer. They are the ultimate victim.
‘If only (insert minority here) didn’t exist. Then my life would be
apples’. Left wing, right wing, religious, irreligious, hate groups
break down a culture like bacteria. So blinded are they by their hate,
they don’t care who gets in the way.
So far, even at their most popular, in Australia hate groups have been
on the fringe. One could argue that One Nation had the ability to bring
these groups into the legitimate world. But that never eventuated.
Instead in Australia, hate groups lurk around the outer rim, with the
disassociated, the disaffected and the disempowered.
One of the best things about Alice Springs is the ability to achieve
pretty much anything you want . But this ability needs to be handled
In Alice Springs, in pubs and coffee shops and community events, you
hear things – a moan or a groan here and there and you don’t think too
much about it. Mostly you roll your eyes and walk away.
But I’ve heard enough of them. I’ve heard the vigilante talk. I’ve
heard the increasing us and them from both us and them. I’ve heard the
call to put law and order into the hands of the people.
Call me an alarmist, but if we don’t fix the problem, if we don’t stop
the talk then it is only a matter of time before this town becomes ripe
picking for an invasion of that most unwelcome aspect of American
In a place where dreams can come true, so can nightmares. The very
proud heart of Australia will suffer its own brand of cultural angina.
Show me a period of history where vigilantism has profited a culture
one iota and I’ll bring the pitchforks. It doesn’t work in the same way
that cancer is never good for the body. If you start attacking the
systems that make a community work then the community fails.
That’s the key. What we don’t need in a failing community is accelerate
systematic breakdown. We need to make the community healthier. And to
do that we need community resolve, political will, substantial
investment and a plan.