Comment on Indigenous art gallery centrepiece of Gunner’s plans for Alice by Ray.
Good concept, but get the popcorn ready. This seems to be suggesting that Aboriginal people are all united, and all see Alice Springs as their cultural home. All the teachings I have had and my understanding is that Australia is made up of 200 to 300 skin or language groups.
I would have thought Mr Paech would be all over this.
Maybe a centre that celebrates Central Australian Aboriginal people, but one that tries to incorporate all skin groups all over the country seems to completely ignore everything cultural awareness lessons have ever taught whitefellas here.
How do you give the same level of representation to the Arrernte and those from the Torres Strait in the one limited building? Surely all the schoolkids from Hobart would be best studying the land, culture, songlines and traditions of Tasmanian Aboriginies, and those from Broome would be better placed to learn about their saltwater people instead.
Take a leaf from places that are successful. In New Zealand, cultural centres concentrate on the Maori, not every inhabitant of the Pacific Islands.
We had a fantastic cultural centre here in the Panorama Guth, until it burnt down, and that concentrated on the desert peoples of Central Australia.
Look at the Desert Park, they concentrate on our part of Australia, and do a fantastic job.
We are a meeting place for Arrernte, Warlpiri, Pit land tribes, Alyawarre and others. Why not keep it at that?
Sections dedicated to these language groups would surely provide plenty of information for tourists who have come all this way to learn about Central Australian Aborigines.
If they want to learn about Yolngu, they will go up north. This current plan seems a bit like designing a centre for European culture, featuring French, Russian, English, Spanish, Greek and Italian cultures. But hey, these Europeans are all white, so they must be they same, Eh?
Maybe the design could be the “Big Caterpillar”.
Ray Also Commented
Indigenous art gallery centrepiece of Gunner’s plans for Alice
Evelyne, please read my comments again. You may have missed my entire point.
Yes, I understand what song lines are and what they mean, but was commenting that we cannot talk about a national Aboriginal centre in the light it is being presented in the story, as the Aboriginal nations are as different as the European nations are.
Despite the fact they live on the same continent, each country is vastly different, although they do share similarities, and have interacted over the centuries.
Song lines occasionally do cross “cultural country boundaries” and protocols exist for members of one tribe crossing into the country of others, and that is where there are indeed some similarities.
All nations and cultures share myths, legends and lore.
My point was, that we need to concentrate on the Central Desert Aboriginal people, as they are the ones that are here, and have the most influence, and are the ones we can consult with.
Saying it is a national Aboriginal centre demonstrates we still don’t get it.
The entrance to this centre should be the first point to explain to visitors that although Aboriginal people inhabit the entire continent, it is made up of hundreds of “countries” and this particular centre celebrates and explains to visitors the uniqueness of the TOs, their descendants and visitors that make up this “region”.
Steve makes a great point to.
I would love top see an indigenous café, staffed by original staff, featuring food using bush tucker, a forecourt with two or three ceremonial dance displays and culture talks, art galleries, basket weaving workshops and maybe tour guides that can on-sell tours to regions that the visitors want to see more of.
Then again, that’s just my vision, and really means nothing until the views and visions of the TOs are invited.
Recent Comments by Ray
Mother of girl denied education contacts Children’s Commissioner
By your judgement it does @ Outraged.
To me it seems like the principle is simply saying that attending these sport and rec activities is a reward for attending school.
Don’t go to school, don’t enjoy the fun trips. It’s a case of dammed if you do and dammed if you don’t.
The other parents (people of the community) seem to agree withy the principle’s stance.
If this principle allows the truants to attend, against the communities’ wishes, it can only lead to the other students playing truant as well.
Be careful with your criticisms, otherwise there will be nobody left to fill these roles in remote communities. As you are eager to criticize in not only this, but the previous report, how much time are you willing to invest to be the personal carer for this girl at school?
They must be joking!
I agree with Chris, I like the building. Very impressive, although I didn’t know about the smart glass. Good to see something new and on such a scale in town, although some people would like to see no growth in town so it could be forever just like that town in that book.
Six-year-old banned from bush school
@ Outraged: Why be so outraged without the facts. There are always two sides to every story, but your first reaction is that the system is racist. After firstly claiming its racist, your next question is: What’s behind this?
Is the principal white or black? If they are white, you fail to mention they have undertaken to make an effort to close the gap by working in such a remote community, and if she is black, it is hardly racism.
How pathetic you sound, tell the world how they treat us.
While you are at it, tell the world of all the funding that is received, tell them about how this principal could simply take a job in an affluent east coast or urban school, but chooses to instead to ensure education for remote Aboriginal kids.
I notice you say nothing about the ones that actually are attending this school.
Your poor bugger me attitude is a disgrace, and is part of the reason the gap will never close. What a shame.
‘If you treat youth like animals …’
Sadly, Janet, you don’t really have much of an idea on this one, but you cover all bases.
You slam corrections staff with the descriptors of being brutal and corrupt, but then say you know many good ones. That’s a good coverall. A bit like saying I’m not racist, I’ve got a couple of mates who are Aboriginal!
When was rehabilitation removed and abuse of rights put in?
Please, Janet, remember that prison guards are not employed as youth workers.
One group works in a prison, one group works with youth. Do you actually realise they are different?
Brutal and sadistic? What examples can you give of prison guards acting like that, in light of the above.
The gassing of the ones at Don Dale? Found by court to be lawful and reasonable.
The youth worker allegedly grabbing a kid around the throat? Not guilty in the Supreme Court, and again on appeal.
The youth worker that slapped a kid? Already dismissed.
The body builder one at the commission the other day, already dismissed, all the above in the public record.
You claim that the abuse we see in the movies is what the lifestyle is in these institutions is really like.
How could you possibly know Janet?
You must want to be seen as the voice of compassion and reason, but your argument is all over the place, and lacking in facts.
You may want to appear as knowledgeable, but you are simply dog whistling for public acceptance of your point of view, and it is way off the mark.
Vinnies in Alice barely surviving
Just read the update. Says a lot about the future of this store, as they simply provide a blanket statement and do not address any of the concerns.
Maybe a statement saying they are surprised by the claims and apologize to the volunteers would help?
Only one has left in the past month? How about how many left before that?
Nothing to address the pricing disparity.
Maybe an individualized response, not some generic, excuse making, cover all response may have shown some hope for this organization.
I think Janet may be right, judging by all the “power phrases” loved by middle management.
How could they try and encourage new volunteers without investigating the current claims?
I think St. Vincent would be shaking his head