Youth crisis: broken window of tolerance

2531 Window of tolerance SM

 

DRAWING by Tamara Cornthwaite.

 

By RAINER CHLANDA

 

I’m writing about what I think are the underlying causes of antisocial behaviour by young people in our town, to acknowledge some efforts that I think are steps in the right direction, and to challenge some common, and what I believe to be unhelpful and damaging misconceptions surrounding it.

 

The reasons behind all children’s behavior are subjective and complex. Generalizations can be misleading, but as products of a common environment some commonalities can be seen.

 

I work in a youth support service where I have regular contact with a small number of youths at risk. Inevitably, and importantly, I have contact with their friends and families.

 

My job involves building strong and trusting relationships from which I can gain insight in to their lives. The framework in which I work teaches me to understand and respond to these young people in the context of unmet needs and the resulting trauma and developmental gaps.

 

It is from my experience of this work, along with the recent memory of my own growing up in Alice Springs, that I speak.

 

I see young people go to the street and gravitate towards anti-social behavior for a number of reasons. They may first stay out late at night because home is unsafe, whereas safety and guidance can be found in numbers on the street from peers.

 

They may begin petty crime, such as stealing food or clothing, as a means of meeting basic needs unmet at home. They are often hungry. What they do is based in necessity and often endures, but in addition to this a culture of behavior emerges.

 

This “street culture” may also develop out of other less tangible needs such as solidarity, self-expression, and a sense of identity.

 

Many crimes committed, such as stealing a car for a joy-ride, rock throwing or property damage, have no measurable gain.

 

But rather than simply calling it criminal, it can be better understood as acts of resistance and protest: Don’t we see this kind of behavior from people around the world when they are deprived of their rights?

 

A CALL TO THE ADULT WORLD

 

The group offers acceptance and a sense of belonging whilst the thrill of law-breaking is a way of expressing anger and a call to the adult world to see their vulnerability.

 

Of course, this cry for help is highly effective; it’s often only when a child is brought into the youth justice system that referrals to support services are made and an intervention takes place.

 

Simultaneously these actions are also ways of asserting a level of control over their lives; if those responsible don’t meet their basic needs (the kind of fundamental needs recognized in the UN’s Convention of the Rights of the Child) a natural response for a child is to take what is not given.

 

So whilst clearly defined boundaries and expectations, as well as age-appropriate discipline are important, what these young people (as anyone) need is to feel safe, nurtured, heard, valued, loved, and a sense of belonging.

 

There is a common trope that the youth are thugs or delinquents and are in need of firm discipline. Some commonly proposed forms are a flogging or to be locked-up.

 

These responses lack nuance, compassion and any potential to rehabilitate young offenders. Indeed, these types of treatment often reproduce the trauma that gives way to and encourages the (maladaptive) behavior we see.

 

Violence will only perpetuate violence and incarceration will further criminalize the young person. Although it may be a sure temporary fix for public safety, ultimately the current prison system achieves the opposite.

 

Despite our juvenile detention system being infamously abusive and damaging, it sadly still better meets some of the needs of its young inmates. It provides security (relative to the outside environments of many detainees) and predictability.

 

SOME SEE INCARCERATION AS PREFERABLE

 

A detained child may be deprived of their freedom, a proper education, nurture or a connection to a positive identity and culture. But the set routine, clear boundaries and the reliable provision of food and shelter will have some of them considering incarceration as preferable to living in their communities.

 

With this comes the obvious consequence of an incentive to re-offend, which is compounded by the galvanizing of the criminal identity formed through networking and bonding with other young offenders in and out of detention.

 

Especially for young people who are easily impressionable and grappling with a sense of who they are, the mere experience of imprisonment entrenches their identity as a criminal and further orientates them to recidivism.

 

The NT Government recently announced they would “overhaul the Youth Justice System” with one measure being rebuilding a presumably less prison-like detention centre away from the adult jail and to implement reforms aimed at focusing on culture and connectedness to family.

 

These changes are surely a step in the right direction, yet if the “system” has done nothing to improve the environment the young person re-enters once released, the revolving doors of the courthouse and detention centre naturally speed up.

 

TRAUMA CHANGES NEUROBIOLOGY

 

A crucial consideration for understanding these young people is the impact of trauma on their neurobiology.

 

Research teaches us that exposure to abuse, especially at a young age, will stunt the development of different regions of the brain as well as hindering effective communication between them.

 

This is experienced as lacking coherent or rational thought and being prone to impulsivity. The impairment of course varies in degrees of severity, but for example, it is common for a traumatized 13 year old to have a neurological development closer to that of an eight year old.

 

Children carrying trauma can have a higher than average metabolic rate (heart rate), resulting from the “fight or flight response” being too frequently activated.

 

In this state their capacity to access their executive functioning region of the brain (responsible for rational thought, planning etc) is reduced and activity in the limbic system (where raw emotion is processed and stress is dealt with) increases.

 

This combined with blood being channeled away from the brain and towards muscles, as well as the release of adrenalin, calls for an extreme response.

 

This understanding of a child’s experience of life must guide our response to them, not the least in sentencing if they are before the courts.

 

A child’s neurology (essentially determining their sense of self) is highly malleable and therefore has excellent potential to be reshaped if the right approach is taken.

 

One core principle employed in my work is called Strength Based Practice. This means the youth worker simply reflects back to the young person their strong qualities, therefore helping them build a proud identity.

 

If the young person is misbehaving you frame your objection to that on the basis that the young person is better than their behavior is suggesting.

 

If a young person is angry or emotionally heightened you know that there is no point in giving instructions as they have very limited access at that time to the region of their brain that receives such information.

 

Instructions, received as more difficult information to process, will only further push the individual out of their window of tolerance.

 

You must give calming, repetitive, simple statements until they have deescalated before discussing the behavior.

 

All professions who engage with youth should receive basic training so that they are trauma informed.

 

Without the understanding of strategies for effective responses to trauma has children unnecessarily triggered and consequentially experiencing exclusion and punishment throughout their upbringing. This has obvious consequences for a child’s understanding of their place in the world.

 

SIMPLISTIC BELIEFS ABOUT FAMILIES

 

There is also a simplistic belief that the families of troubled youths don’t care about them. I instead see loving people caught in a vicious cycle of profound grief, poverty and hopelessness inherited from trauma over generations.

 

I see people struggling to navigate between the two worlds they’re faced with; between cultural obligations and demands of contemporary society, between lore and law.

 

Amongst these families I’m privileged to meet people who rise above the immense adversity they’re faced with and dedicate their lives to looking after their often extensive families.

 

Disproportionately these individuals are women, women who take in the children of relatives who aren’t coping, often in addition to their own. The responsibility of caring for several more lives is compounded by the complex needs these children are likely to possess when coming from dysfunction.

 

In the event where it is determined that the capacity of those caring for a child can’t be strengthened to a degree where the child’s needs are met, I feel an obvious early intervention would be to channel resources to intensively support those who can provide culturally appropriate and meaningful care to these children.

 

Currently “kinship’’ placements are sought before a child is removed and taken into care. If successful and a relative registers the care of child they’ll receive an additional family tax benefit from Centrelink. This added income, although necessary, is far from sufficient.

 

Basic support such as help with grocery shopping, school enrolments, transport to sporting activities and respite for the legal guardian may be the difference between a single responsible adult managing, and them breaking down, leaving the children once again vulnerable.

 

It is irrational to bemoan such expenditure if it can allow a child to stay with kin as opposed to Out of Home Care or Youth Justice System, both infinitely more expensive and offering less hope for the young person.

 

Greater efforts should be made to establish care arrangements where young people remain with family. This option is viable in Aboriginal communities in particular as it is highly cultural to take care of a relative’s child.

 

I’ve supported families in making hard decisions involving their children going to a relative or friend and have seen the result as empowering and relieving.

 

This is in stark contrast to a child being taken into government care, which, needless to say, echoes the Stolen Generation experience and is highly distressing for both the child and family.

 

Furthermore, the threshold at which action is warranted needs to be lowered if we are to honor the early intervention principle.

 

Instead of requiring substantiated abuse before an investigation takes place, a home visit and offer of engaging in voluntary cooperation where the families are empowered and supported in addressing their child’s concern should occur if, for example, they are recorded frequently on the Youth Bus after midnight (a free bus for youth that conveys them home and records the names of all passengers) or observed to be regularly hungry or tired at school.

 

Of course, I sympathise with business owners who struggle to stay afloat as a result of incessant break-ins, and residents who don’t feel safe in their own homes.

 

But to achieve real change our response must not be based on what we feel we have a right to, such as punishment or compensation, but what we can do to help the young, vulnerable and so often traumatized children who are committing many of these offences.

 

Initiatives such as well devised recreational youth programs, progressive reforms in the Youth Justice System, or social engineering measures around alcohol restrictions, are all important. But as long our youth’s fundamental needs continue to go unmet this issue will remain.

 

 

 

Be Sociable, Share!

31 Comments (starting with the most recent)

NB: If you want to reply to a previous comment, start your comment with this notation: @n where n is the number of the comment you want to reply to.
  1. Posted May 2, 2018 at 7:24 am

    Well done Rainer for humanising the anti-social behaviour of youth, talking about emotional experiences,fostering psychological understanding and for locating the bevaviour in transgenerational trauma.

    View Comment
  2. Carolyn Newman
    Posted April 26, 2018 at 4:09 pm

    Thanks Rainer!

    View Comment
  3. Posted April 20, 2018 at 3:51 pm

    Praiseworthy insights, Rainer. I add my voice to all those who’ve endorse your summary.

    View Comment
  4. Jonathan Pilbrow
    Posted April 19, 2018 at 9:44 pm

    Thanks Rainer for your most insightful and helpful article.
    Re: “All professions who engage with youth should receive basic training so that they are trauma informed.”
    Do all police receive training in trauma informed practice?
    If not – this would seem to be one immediate priority that could be actioned.

    View Comment
  5. Gerlinde Bothin
    Posted April 19, 2018 at 2:10 pm

    Brilliant, in-depth, concise and cutting edge analysis, empowered by your deep compassion, humanity and hope for the young people in this town and their communities! I can’t thank you enough for this inspiring article, Rainer!

    View Comment
  6. Ruth Gawler
    Posted April 18, 2018 at 8:40 pm

    I found this to be informative, showing deep understanding, having Positive Psychology support in terms of evidence for the success of the methods, and optimistic, in the best possible way. Very happy to read this eloquent, compassionate response to such a distressing situation.

    View Comment
  7. Posted April 17, 2018 at 12:14 pm

    Great article Rainer. Very insightful. Good on you.

    View Comment
  8. Marina Strocchi
    Posted April 17, 2018 at 10:48 am

    Thank you for a very enlightening article. Tenacity and empathy in your work too. Good on you and your colleagues. In Melbourne there is a thing called BOUNCE – an aircraft hanger style shed jam packed with all variations of trampolines and foam pits. It’s proven that trampolines aid in rewiring a traumatized brain – it’s got something to do with repetition and physical activity – how good would that be in Alice Springs? All the best to you.

    View Comment
  9. Hal Duell
    Posted April 16, 2018 at 2:23 pm

    As noted by all the comments so far, this is an excellent article, well reasoned and well presented.
    But to engage with the marginalised youth in Alice in a positive manner, a venue is needed. Such a venue is at hand. The old Anzac High School would fill that bill admirably.
    I hope our Town Council reads this article and carefully considers whether a MOU with Darwin concerning the proposed art gallery, which would destroy that high school building in a quest for more tourist dollars and a dubious attempt to reinvigorate the CBD, is really more important than attempting to address the very real youth social issues plaguing Alice Springs.

    View Comment
  10. Georgina Pratt
    Posted April 16, 2018 at 2:06 pm

    Thank you for a very timely article.
    Surely as a society we recognise the “system isn’t working”, and are now willing to look beyond.
    Dr Gabor Matè is coming “down under”. He is the keynote speaker at The International Childhood Trauma Conference, held here in Melbourne August 2018.

    View Comment
  11. Stephanie Harrison
    Posted April 16, 2018 at 8:45 am

    “All professions who engage with youth should receive basic training so that they are trauma informed.”
    Solid truths in here Rainer. Thank you.

    View Comment
  12. Pip McManus
    Posted April 15, 2018 at 2:56 pm

    Thanks Rainer for such a well considered and compassionate observation of the issues underlying youth disaffection and crime in our town. Every child needs a resourceful and caring adult, preferably family, to look out for them – every day. A starting point for this government would be to devote more energy and resources into assisting responsible kin to provide the basic needs of food and safety.

    View Comment
  13. Del Hird
    Posted April 15, 2018 at 11:59 am

    Congratulations Rainer. This is by far the best article that I have read about this issue in a long time.
    First and foremost you have captured the essentials of research and reflective practice to present a positive view of a very complex issue.
    You have presented this in such a logical framework that everyone should be able to understand.
    I sincerely hope that a high percentage of our population gets to read it.
    Love to see it posted on FB on A/S Community Forum instead of half of the junk that we see on there.

    View Comment
  14. Psuedo Guru
    Posted April 15, 2018 at 10:25 am

    Fantastic efforts- BUT Law and Order problems remain?

    View Comment
  15. Tom Penny
    Posted April 14, 2018 at 11:03 pm

    An eloquently written article from the man with the most impeccable kickflips in Alice Springs. Bravo.

    View Comment
  16. Shirleen
    Posted April 14, 2018 at 8:58 pm

    Rainer, I like what you have written here and I see very clearly that you are passionate about our young people. I personally would like to see Youth Accommodations or Safe Houses for our street kids who can have their basic human rights met. We need Youth Workers who will be there for them 25/7 to see these young people grow up to be very proud individuals. I’d like to see that.

    View Comment
  17. Suzanne Visser
    Posted April 14, 2018 at 5:58 pm

    Yes, Rainer, exactly, yes. Thank you!

    View Comment
  18. Russell Goldflam
    Posted April 14, 2018 at 4:51 pm

    What an incisive, perceptive, big-hearted and clear-headed contribution! Thank you, Rainer, not only for your penetrating observation and analysis, but also for the terrific work you and your colleagues do every day (and night) with young people in our community.

    View Comment
  19. Posted April 14, 2018 at 3:17 pm

    This is a clear distillation of much of what has been said in these pages for a number of years by many people trying to rationalise the progressive liberalism which has left a legacy of seven days per week takeaway alcohol.
    Social engineering is a term used to describe social movements and their effect, but present alcohol reform is deconstructing modern social policy by trying to rationalise liberal supply and its pathology.
    The Cultural Revolution that brought sex, drugs and rock ‘n’ roll to the post-war generation, many of whom became politicians, is as much implicated as anything else when it comes to determining the kind of values societies need to follow in a postmodern world.

    View Comment
  20. Posted April 14, 2018 at 8:40 am

    A brilliantly presented article, Rainer, and one I hope our community and political decision-makers will read and take on board. You give us hope for a brighter future.

    View Comment
  21. Penelope
    Posted April 14, 2018 at 7:56 am

    Rainer, a refreshing clear perspective. Shifting resources and community focus to supporting youth and children and their families delivered with love and care, would make such a difference to the trajectory of Alice Springs.
    The saying is so true: “It takes a community to raise a child.”

    View Comment
  22. Anjali Palmer
    Posted April 14, 2018 at 7:29 am

    Thank you for your insights and your work Rainer. Sincerely hope people understand and learn from these, for it’s only when we take the time to do so that we will be able to make changes for the better in our communities.

    View Comment
  23. Posted April 14, 2018 at 7:03 am

    This is a brilliant article, Rainer, a valuable contribution to public discourse that will stand the test of time.
    Much of what you have written has been observed before, and much of what you describe is instantly recognisable from the time of my own childhood here in Alice Springs.
    However, when I was young there was a sense of the corner having been turned when the NT achieved Self-government and there was great hope for the future. Things were about to change for the better for everyone.
    I feel a sense of deep disappointment combined with great anger that nothing has improved for so many people in the Territory, and generation after generation of young people born here find themselves “coping” in life conditions no better – and, in many cases, far worse – than the supposedly “bad old days” of Commonwealth control.
    It’s equally profoundly disappointing that the energy and intellect of young people such as yourself, Rainer, are left to pick up the pieces of a failed legacy of earlier generations.
    But it’s wonderful that you are doing so, and that’s why hope survives.

    View Comment
  24. Jocelyn Davies
    Posted April 14, 2018 at 4:58 am

    Thanks for your insights, Rainer.

    View Comment
  25. Peter Dixon
    Posted April 13, 2018 at 11:05 pm

    An excellent article. Thank you, Rainer.

    View Comment
  26. Lizzie Gilliam
    Posted April 13, 2018 at 9:04 pm

    Well-written and thought-provoking article. Well done, Rainer.

    View Comment
  27. Careful with that axe, Eugene
    Posted April 13, 2018 at 8:51 pm

    A very clear and intelligent presentation of key facts concerning the situations of many of the young people who run wild in our streets at night, Rainer. I hope many Alice residents take the time to read it properly.
    I particularly appreciated the clarity of your reference to the role that entry to the police and justice system (and later imprisonment) plays in the formation of the identities of many of these kids (to quote: “Especially for young people who are easily impressionable and grappling with a sense of who they are, the mere experience of imprisonment entrenches their identity as a criminal and further orientates them to recidivism.”)
    If only more people realised the importance of this insight, and appreciated the folly of failing to respond sensibly and intelligently to this key contradiction.

    View Comment
  28. Jess Matteson
    Posted April 13, 2018 at 8:31 pm

    Thank you for both sharing your personal and professional experience and knowledge but more so this is the clearest expression of youth in Alice I have read.
    It makes complete sense, and really also shines a light into many people of all ages and race problems that so often are stereotyped or scapegoated in society.
    There generally needs to be a shift towards compassion and care if this town is going to progress, as does the whole world carry issues and attitudes to do with mental illness, substance abuse and criminal activity.
    I hope people can receive this information and consider it before jumping onto typical bandwagon or banter that gets nobody anywhere.

    View Comment
  29. Jimmy Cocking
    Posted April 13, 2018 at 8:07 pm

    Thank you Rainer for sharing your insights and experience. The more we all seek to understand the vulnerable youth in our community and support the needs of families, the better it will be. Keep up the good work.

    View Comment
  30. Fiona
    Posted April 13, 2018 at 7:55 pm

    This article is brilliant. Concise, insightful, informative and penned by a local to boot! I wish more people in our community could understand this logic.

    View Comment
  31. Richard Bentley
    Posted April 13, 2018 at 6:15 pm

    Thankyou for sharing your insights through your experience, Rainer.
    You can expect plenty of criticism from some quarters but please stay strong.
    We have the resources and the intelligence in this country to make life better for everyone.

    View Comment

Post a Comment

Your email is never shared. Required fields are marked *

*
*