Oh, Janet. Life must be so simple when you are …

Comment on Asylum seeker led recovery for Alice: businessman’s proposal by Domenico Pecorari.

Oh, Janet. Life must be so simple when you are guided by nothing more than chasing buckets of money with which to solve all our problems … but you and others like you, all looking for silver bullet solutions, need to consider the consequences of your ideas. Have you, for example, given any thought to, or quantified, the pros and cons of having an onshore refugee processing centre, both in the short and longer term? If you have, then by all means let us in on the data that underpins your idea.
When you are able to give more than unsubstantiated opinions, your ideas may be more worthy of consideration.

Domenico Pecorari Also Commented

Asylum seeker led recovery for Alice: businessman’s proposal
Now, Jan, I have re-read Paul’s article, and nowhere do I find ANY details regarding the form of accommodation proposed, apart from references to “onshore processing of refugees” as opposed to offshore processing in Malaysia, Christmas Island and Nauru. The release of refugees holding bridging visas into the community was first raised by Hal Duell, with whom I agreed, in writing, stating also that I did not accept any form of processing involving detention centres. As I said before, I believe there are lots of details to work through and I’d still want to see some analysis work before any decisions are made. As for your assertion that I’ve labelled this town’s conservatives as “white racists”, I challenge you to find any such references in my writings. It did, however, remind me of that saying: “If the hat fits …”

Asylum seeker led recovery for Alice: businessman’s proposal
If we are talking about integrated community-based accommodation of asylum seekers, as opposed to a detention centre, then I am all for it. As you say yourself, Hal, there’s “lots of details to work through”. I just want to see some analysis before we proclaim “Yes, let’s do it!”.

Asylum seeker led recovery for Alice: businessman’s proposal
Judging from the poorly thought out support shown for this half baked idea, it must be time we officially changed our town’s name to Alice $PRING$: always chasing that bucket of money, at all costs.

Recent Comments by Domenico Pecorari

Big drops in grog crime, break-ins on way down: police
I’m sorry for James T Smirk, Jack and David, who have to grab at straws such as alleged under-reporting, maligning do-gooders and rejecting the figures in favour of a tougher stance on offenders.
It would seem the statistics are stacked against you, based as they are upon the actual numbers of offenders being taken into protective custody and presentations at the hospital’s emergency department. Cold, hard facts, I’d have thought.
Is it possible that some in our community cannot accept the link between anti-social behaviour / domestic violence and unbridled access to take-away alcohol?
I agree with Watching and Maya.
Let us be glad for the progress made to date and look to how the situation may be improved for the future. Nay-sayers need not apply.

Blackout: Managers must go, says union source
What a monumental mess indeed.
Ten new gas-fired generators that cannot be relied upon to deal with fluctuations in demand; the former Ron Goodin generator not maintained to provide back-up if needed; what seems to be an undersized back-up battery system and remote management of the power system from Darwin …
The Electrical Trades Union is correct in calling for heads to roll.
An opportunity also for the Minister, Dale Wakefield, to either show courage or to reward incompetence.
Alice Springs deserves better.

Old visitors centre trashed
@ Evelyn: All around Australia, councils are taking up the challenges that our so-called “leaders” in Canberra (and at state and territory level) are either unable or unwilling to deal with. Climate change, to name but one.
Whilst it would seem that our local council has had its internal divisions and a lack of coherent leadership, I believe things are about to change.
Over the last year, AS Town Council has approved the development of a Town Plan for Alice and it has recently appointed a new CEO with the qualifications and experience to turn it into reality.
I do not have a problem with councillors having their own dreams, so long as these are incorporated into a broader vision that will improve our town’s ability to face an uncertain future.

How do NT Labor and the CLP rate on heritage?
That’s very true, Alex. There are countless articles on the contribution that heritage makes towards thriving tourist destinations.
The Alice had this in the mid-1980s, when I first came to town, with a distinctive character that I used to tell my city friends you could “carve with a knife”.
Decades of pro-business re-development and poor civic leadership has seen the town’s unique character reduced to where we are today: Little more than a service town for a much diminished local tourism industry and a declining permanent population.
Sadly, the notion of “A Town Like Alice” has been well and truly killed off.
I have come to believe that the only hope for the town’s revival is for it to re-invent itself as a centre that is successfully meeting the many and varied challenges of an uncertain future.
Such a new “identity” would not only pay homage to the the hard work and hopes of central Australia’s earliest pioneers, but has the potential to make Alice a place that people would once again want to visit and make their home.

Election 2020 salvos fired with Alice the first battleground
@ Trevor Shiell. Whilst it is true that we have many plans, what our town lacks is a comprehensive plan, the overall vision, that these more detailed plans ought to be developed from.
These individual plans often pull in opposing directions, are too narrowly focused and do not take into account a big picture of the town we want The Alice to develop into, a vision drawn up not only from an economic point of view, but also from an environmental, social and cultural perspective.
Until we do that, we will continue to chase our tail and waste time, dwindling resources and funding, as so well illustrated by the latest fiasco over the Aboriginal Art Gallery.

Be Sociable, Share!

A new way to support our journalism

We do not have a paywall. If you support our independent journalism you can make a financial contribution by clicking the red button below. This will help us cover expenses and sustain the news service we’ve been providing since 1994, in a locally owned and operated medium.

Erwin Chlanda, Editor