Murdoch’s Centralian Advocate probes Alice Springs News Online – and engages in selective quoting

UPDATE Fri Aug 31, 2pm: The Centralian Advocate today has printed only part of the story – a clear attempt to make me and this publication look bad.


Citing public interest as its motive, the Murdoch paper invited me to respond to questions and to comment. I did – but the Advocate left out the most salient detail. My statement to reporter Brooks was: “I have no debts other than to Forrest …”


Just in case she didn’t get it: I don’t owe a cent to anyone except David Forrest. – ERWIN CHLANDA




The Murdoch-owned Centralian Advocate is making enquiries about the Alice Springs News Online and its editor, Erwin Chlanda.


We received the following email on Tuesday, signed “Sally Brooks, Journalist, Centralian Advocate” saying: “I have been following the Randal Carey case and came across information that you were declared bankrupt in June.


“I also saw a new business, Alice Springs News Online, was registered on May 16, 2012, the same day the court case in which David Forrest applied to bankrupt you, started.


“I am writing a story about this for the paper, and wondered if you would like to respond?”


Mr Chlanda replied: “It was I who applied for bankruptcy and my application was granted. David Forrest’s application did not proceed.


“I have no debts other than to Forrest, formerly a principal of Framptons First National Real Estate, pursuant to a defamation judgment.


“In what context is the Alice Springs News Online registration being raised? It is not a business but a business name, and the registration is not in my name.


“Are there specific questions you wish to put? I would certainly like to respond.”


On Wednesday Ms Brooks sent further questions, saying they related to the public interest of the story:-


Q: Does your bankruptcy jeopardise the trading of Alice Springs News?


A: The Alice Springs News Online is continuing with a new management structure.


Q: Is it ‘business as usual’ for you?


A: I used to be the Managing Editor, now I am the Editor.


Q: What is the relationship of the business name Alice Springs News Online to


A: Alice Springs News Online more accurately reflects our current activity.


Q: If there is a relationship, why was the business name registered on the same day the Forrest bankruptcy application started?


A: You have your facts wrong.




The defamation action arose from one report in a long series of stories, most of them exclusive, about the Frampton New Homes scheme which collapsed in 2010, with a dozen home buyers losing a lot of money, not to mention peace of mind. (Reports can be googled on this site.)


The critical content of the report sued on was changed at the earliest possible opportunity (the following edition), without Mr Forrest even having contacted us.


The court this year delivered an entirely one-sided judgement and awarded the maximum payment of $100,000 plus interest to Mr Forrest who has since left town. I had a credible defence, based on carefully articulated legal principles drafted by barristers, but I did not have the resources to employ a legal team. I had to represent myself to the best of my ability.


As I have said before, the way our society deals with defamation must be reformed. The present procedures are a major impediment to our freedom of speech, with whoever has the deeper pockets being a critical factor in the outcome.


I am Alice Springs’ longest serving journalist, arriving in 1974, and ever since have provided news about Central Australia for print and television media here, interstate and overseas.


During the half century in my profession, having never before had a defamation judgment against me, I risked my life covering armed conflicts in Nigeria and Biafra (before emigrating from my native Austria), in Afghanistan (embedded with a Mujahideen group behind Soviet lines), and Cambodia during the UN sponsored elections.


My colleague and wife Kieran Finnane and I founded the weekly Alice Springs News in 1994 as the first ever sustained, locally owned and controlled newspaper. In March last year the News went exclusively online. Our online edition (as an adjunct to the print edition) had started in 1997 – among the nation’s first internet newspapers.


And now, in the public interest, we have a question for the Centralian Advocate: Where was it when a dozen local families formed the Framptons New Homes Broken Promises group in response to dealings by Frampton New Homes between late 2008 and mid-2010?






Be Sociable, Share!

A new way to support our journalism

We do not have a paywall. If you support our independent journalism you can make a financial contribution by clicking the red button below. This will help us cover expenses and sustain the news service we’ve been providing since 1994, in a locally owned and operated medium.

Erwin Chlanda, Editor

6 Comments (starting with the most recent)

NB: If you want to reply to a previous comment, start your comment with this notation: @n where n is the number of the comment you want to reply to.
  1. Carolyn Connell
    Posted February 1, 2016 at 6:21 pm

    I had over a thousand dollars of 50c pieces stolen from my property at the Gap, if anyone has any information please contact police. They are limited edition. Reward offered.

    View Comment
  2. Graeme Henderson
    Posted September 9, 2012 at 8:51 pm

    As a longtime journalist and country newspaper editor now retired, and a irregular but reasonably frequent visitor to Alice Springs, I want to say how much respect I have for Erwin (whom I have never met by the way) and his fearless and factual reporting. And I know the difficulties of fighting an unjustified defamation case. All power to you and the Alice Spring News.

    View Comment
  3. Kim Petersen
    Posted September 7, 2012 at 9:52 am

    Like a lot of things in Alice Springs, mainly in the last 10 years, if everyone is controlled by the government stalling of progress by almost forcing developers into a corner on available land, which is were all this type of panic comes from, you have a developer that needs a return on investment, that is a profit on land sale, with a package deal having to be thought up, probably with very little margin for the actual builder to deliver on time, and on budget, not to mention problems with finding good reliable workers that complete each stage on time. Very sad, Hendo!

    View Comment
  4. Harold Gimlet
    Posted August 31, 2012 at 3:55 pm

    The lady doth protest too much, methinks.

    View Comment
  5. Gavin and Joan Carpenter
    Posted August 31, 2012 at 10:00 am

    If the Advocate put the time and effort in, chased and printed news like the Alice News and had a web page, sales would no doubt soar. Long live Alice News.

    View Comment
  6. Philip Selman
    Posted August 30, 2012 at 3:48 pm

    Dear Erwin,
    Unfortunately I don’t reside in Alice anymore but hope to return in the future. However even though I’m 3000 klms away your publication always keeps me well informed with your without fear or favour reporting and more so, your papers’ comment section where the readers can also immediately comment on the reports.
    I used to buy and read the Centralian Advocate when I lived in Alice but now I can’t, why? Because they have no online presence. Maybe what the Centralian Advocate really want is your advice and inside knowledge on how to get their paper on line as successfully as yours, and this is just their awkward way of getting your attention.
    Regards, Phil Selman.

    View Comment

Post a Comment

Your email is never shared. Required fields are marked *