I agree with Steve Brown, Jimmy IS naive. For thinking …

Comment on Council wants more time to respond to water plan by Ian Sharp.

I agree with Steve Brown, Jimmy IS naive. For thinking he could have a rational debate with Steve, without personal attacks and pigeon-holing.
As for the issue of water, the idea of cap to stimulate better water conservation practices and new technologies makes sense, to get the best out of existing borefields.
There may be plenty of water further out, but that involves extra infrastructure and operating costs that we could avoid for some time if we are less profligate.

Ian Sharp Also Commented

Council wants more time to respond to water plan
@ Steve … are you saying I am being hypocritical (if so, in what way? Don’t you believe me when I say I hold the belief that you are often irrational and rude in your responses on this website, am I only pretending do you think?)
Or are you saying I am being hyper-critical, too hard on you, that I should make allowances for you in some way, on account of your … what?
Just asking. And I will forgo the pleasure of sharing a dugout with Jimmy, thanks for the suggestion, but I am sure he is quite capable of making his own arrangements to deal with your outbursts.
I would be interested, however, in a more rational and thoughtful discussion of the issues related to our water. I think a cap might be useful, but we need to know more about the demands that mining might place on the resource, and how that will be dealt with.

Recent Comments by Ian Sharp

Council on climate: wide-ranging action as matter of urgency
Well done Erwin for allowing Alex Nelson to post the link to The Conversation article.

We won’t be there for His Royal Highness
How silly is this! How long will we put up with this nonsense of having this lot “rule over us”?

Rules for outback work travel may catch some out
A woman I knew back in the 1980s or 90s was required to drive a Landcruiser out bush alone without the knowledge or capability to change a wheel if she had a flat. Luckily it never happened.

Value of NT mineral production highest ever
In 2017-18 our mineral resource exports, including base metals, earned Australia more than $220bn (total exports exceeded $400bn for the first time).
Hard to judge (because NT figure quoted here doesn’t include oil and gas, and not all Australian production is exported) but it still seems the NT’s production value of $5bn is not much.
On the upside that indicates there is a huge potential for future exploration and development.

Hate speech report sparks trolling
Suzi Wankapai is spot on.

Be Sociable, Share!

A new way to support our journalism

We do not have a paywall. If you support our independent journalism you can make a financial contribution by clicking the red button below. This will help us cover expenses and sustain the news service we’ve been providing since 1994, in a locally owned and operated medium.

Erwin Chlanda, Editor