Sarah@5. It seems you are really trying to discredit a …

Comment on Cover-up: Australia’s or Pilger’s? by Ray.

Sarah@5. It seems you are really trying to discredit a review on this movie.
Another such movie that is in a similar vein to this one is rabbit proof fence, where much of the content was said to be simply untrue by the person who was the central character.
You ask Kieran to provide evidence of things that did not occur? How anybody can do that is beyond me.
You are horrified by a statistic that 10 percent died, but let’s put that in perspective, we were talking about the turn of the century, way, way before medicine was developed enough to diagnose and treat many common diseases.
I think they were lucky that the figure was that low. As Kieran said, there is information available to the tourists who wish to find out the history of the place. What you are trying to do in impose today’s standards on a society as it existed 100 years ago.
Yes, we did have a pretty rough past, but what colonial power didn’t? I am glad that Kieran did this review, and although it does not support your wish that we should all hang our heads in shame, it is comforting to know that there are journalists who are prepared to dig a little deeper, and provide an alternative source of information.
This is the reason I enjoy reading the Alice Springs News Online, and hope they continue to provide a source of information that challenges the standard media crap we are so often fed.

Recent Comments by Ray

Cops at bottle shops: expensive bluff?
Good to see some stats from Vicki, the correlation cannot be just coincidence.
As far as profiling goes, excellent.
There already is profiling for jobs in the form of special measure, and as police have said to me personally, if I know the bloke trying to purchase a bottle of Jacks is going to and his wife to hospital, he will do it.
Nice to see coppers who are not afraid to apply common sense.
I bought a carton the other night and was asked for ID, so to say it does not happen is erroneous. Once again, the PALI scheme is working according to the stats.


Anti-fracking Greens: Are jobs for the dole schemes legal?
John Argent: Your arguments have more holes that the rabbit proof fence itself.
If you are quoting that movie as a source of facts you may want to pick a better example.
If you google “holes in the rabbit proof fence” you will find plenty of info on it.
Even the person it is supposed to be about has said: “That’s not my story.”
It’s a bit like saying Jack and Rose were real people and using the movie Titanic to base your story.
As far as the White Australia policy goes, you use that as justification for the Aborigines finding the others in the bush.
You fail to understand the white Australia Policy had absolutely nothing to do with Aboriginal people. It was to do with immigration, pure and simple.
And as far as calling somebody a coconut, it is a racial slur, no matter who uses it.
If you you use it yourself then congratulations, you Sir are a racist, as racism goes both ways and being Aboriginal, African, Asian or any other colour does not give you an exemption.


Anti-fracking Greens: Are jobs for the dole schemes legal?
Unfortunately, Darwin Observer, you are correct in the way it is supposed to work, and in this case would be the Crown (Commonwealth or State) and regulated by either Comcare or Worksafe that is the regulator and responsible for enforcing the NUL WHS Act.
Unfortunately an Aboriginal worker on CDEP had a serious accident with an angle grinder, which he should have had training and instruction in using, yet he was unable to claim compensation as he was not a worker as defined by the Return to Work Act, and neither worksafe nor Comcare have said they are able to prosecute (or don’t want to) due to the way it is structured.
This should be one of the first things they should nut out as part of any planned changes to CDP or CDEP.


Whenever you need a cop … there are three
Culturally respectful? Seriously. Telling a criminal they should stop bashing a person that won’t hurt their feelings, in language.
We are losing the war on sanity very quickly.


Rock, Alice: Widening the gap
Maybe a vision like making of of the world’s great train journeys even better by dealing with the owners of the Ghan railway and building a track to The Rock, make the Alice the centre again, and offer a four or five hour service to The Rock.
The line could be expanded in future to be a cross continental journey to Perth following the Outback Way through The Centre.
Fewer trucks means less road maintenance, and maybe more passengers across all services could reduce the costs.
Even a historic train such as the Old Ghan or a replica to do the trip.
With a car carrying ability, it could transform the self drive market and increase visitation to both places.
Would love an express service to Darwin where you could unload and drive your own car, rather than expensive airfares then hiring a car.


Be Sociable, Share!

A new way to support our journalism

We do not have a paywall. If you support our independent journalism you can make a financial contribution by clicking the red button below. This will help us cover expenses and sustain the news service we’ve been providing since 1994, in a locally owned and operated medium.

Erwin Chlanda, Editor