“The only answer I can come up with is that …

Comment on NGOs, who needs them? by Arthur Bell.

“The only answer I can come up with is that they allow governments to divest themselves of responsibility, make the inevitable failings when dealing with difficult social issues, someone else’s responsibility”.
You got that right, Steve.
And this: “Given that no-one actually owns the NGO, governance if it exists at all is often poor, there is no incentive to operate profitably, they become fat, lazy and incompetent.”
This is actually happening nationally. And has been for quite a few years.
You can throw in, “people end up taking ownership of jobs” and in many cases, “the organisations and property themselves”! With very little fear of dismissal or even censorship.
There are many instances of this behaviour. Due in part to political correctness.
Quote: “Over the last 10 years, 1894 defunct corporations or corporations that are no longer operating have been deregistered.” I got this information from ORIC a couple of years back.
Once the initial funding ran out, many initiatives, projects and organisations were / are virtually abandoned. “Self determination” a flawed concept and failed experiment.
ORIC has to take some responsibility for this continuing situation.
I think I’ve covered these issues on my website.
And Janet has raised some good points.

Recent Comments by Arthur Bell

Rosalie Kunoth-Monks ‘not welcome’ in her community
Thanks Paul, it looks like I’ll have to go through all that stuff on my site again to see what you are referring to! But that’s alright, as I try to do it whenever my health allows, and as time goes by, anyway.
To re-edit and sometimes to moderate my published or stated view, over a number of years.
“For many to move on means forget what happened, until it happens again … then complain again until decide forget it”.
A couple of things here, as I see it, in the future of multiculturalism governance, the above options will simply, not be available. It will not be a continuing saga a la “days of our lives”.
Like what happened 227 years ago, there will be major disruptions of the way of life in this Country. And the only people that have a historical or any moral obligation to the descendants of the original inhabitants, as has already been pointed out, will no longer dominate or be in charge.


Will the NT also stop funding outstations?
For many years now Aboriginal people living a traditional or semi-traditional lifestyle, have been lulled into a false sense of security. By do-gooders and the misguided. And by the ignorant and the mischievous. (alb. c. 06/2013.)


Rosalie Kunoth-Monks ‘not welcome’ in her community
“Time to move on. What we’re talking about is history. If we don’t start moving on, the foreigners coming into this country, coming here to make their home, will walk all over us.”
This is the what I try to alert my fellow indigenous to.


Self help not part of the welfare mantra
Wasted conversation this bloke, Erwin. Thought you would’ve seen that! Ex Oxfam crusader a la John Pilger. With all the answers. No solutions, but all the answers.


Firebrands United: Block gas, oil production, says Anderson
We have the Sovereignty Mob. Then the Recognise Mob. The Treaty Mob. With the Aboriginal Provisional Government. And the National Congress.
Some very determined, articulate and well paid Blackfellas.
Some very seasoned campaigners. As Stephen Hagan would say, “the usual suspects”. And most ideologically opposed.
With views and agendas incompatible. And some might say, “with heads buried in the sand”.
“They” want to be in charge. “They” want to run the show.
And all the rest of us Blackfellas have to follow “their” solutions and agendas. Apparently. Evidently. Whether we want to or not. Whether we “agree” to or not. Whether we “like” it or not. All on their own trip. Many are a law unto themselves.
Many of these prominent long time long term Aboriginal activists, agitators and media and self-appointed so-called leaders, they have to take a lot of responsibility for where we are today. A lot of what’s happening today developed on their watch.
And it can be argued that they have failed us. With trillions of dollars generated in the name of and in the cause of, the advancement and the betterment of the Aboriginal and Islander People of Australia.
A failed exercise in economic independence and self determination. With many wasted opportunities. Not to forget the money. WASTED. SQUANDERED. Aboriginal Rights?


Be Sociable, Share!

A new way to support our journalism

We do not have a paywall. If you support our independent journalism you can make a financial contribution by clicking the red button below. This will help us cover expenses and sustain the news service we’ve been providing since 1994, in a locally owned and operated medium.

Erwin Chlanda, Editor