The inquiry’s reference to Silent Spring is an abhorrent and …

Comment on Inquiry into fracking: Giving it the green light? by Defiant.

The inquiry’s reference to Silent Spring is an abhorrent and perverted tactic to legitimise an industry that offers nothing but greed, contamination and conflict.
Carson would be turning in her grave if she knew her ideas were being used in this way.
Fracking of shale gas in the US has lead to a contamination legacy comparably only to the days of DDT and other pesticides. It is an environmental catastrophe and we know this.
That fundamental flaw in this inquiry is the consistent use of subjective terms in an objective way. What is meant when they conclude risk can be mitigated to an acceptable level?
Is that one contaminated aquifer? Is that a 1% increase in premature births? Is it .1% increase in warming? Is it a 2% increase in road fatalities?
They don’t decide what risk is acceptable, that is not a question for science or law.
That is one for the people of the NT to decide and they have decided. No risk is worth the financial gain that is made by a few select corporate individuals.

Recent Comments by Defiant

Salt mines and tourism: bread and circuses
@ Lyndsay: Fair enough to be in defence of facts and a balanced discussion on projects yet you provide no material to actually substantiate such a balance.
You say the company has been transparent, could you please tell us exactly what waste the company intends to store? Could you tell us where it is coming from and how much will be coming?
Could you please tell us how a company which intends to leave the project after 25 years, will be able to safeguard the community and environment for hundreds of years? Will the company be paying royalties to the local community or the NT Government? Is there a waste royalty?
Your assumption that disposal is a fait accompli is also misguided.
The vast majority of waste we produce could be managed more responsibly than dumping it in the ground to forget about.
Yet this company is seeking to profit from final disposal only. Can you really see someone digging up the waste from the salt to ship it out of Alice? Let’s get real here.
Waste is a dirty game and our system is fraught and broken. We can’t sort out our recycling issue let alone the safe and responsible management of hazardous waste.
This project is an opportunistic reaction to a problem that deserves national attention and clear Federal government policy.

Youth crime: compassion alone is no solution
Erwin, you have not added anything positive or constructive. While you allege The Guardian article was misleading, you have done nothing here but the fan flames of controversy.
You have not offered any ways forward to help prevent crime nor alleviate the suffering of young people in detention. All you have done is criticise someone for writing in support of compassion.
Compassion, kindness and care is sorely missing from our public debates and discussion on this issue. It is disappointing that you have missed this opportunity to support a legitimate and well informed position on a painful topic.

Back to the future with Warren Snowdon
Labor have committed $1.5bn to gas infrastructure across the Beetaloo and Queensland.
Stating that the “The Commonwealth engagement is merely through the Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act and the water trigger” is therefore factually incorrect.

The festival of lights – and phones 
A constitutionally enshrined voice to parliament for Australia’s First Nations people is an issue of national urgency. The history of our federal parliament has been to design laws that have created dispossession, oppression, disease and poverty for Aboriginal people. This needs to stop and a key part of that is ensuring that laws are developed with advice from First Nations people.

This was expressed at Parrtjima by Thomas Mayor who gave a call to action for people to ensure the Uluru Statement from the Heart is an election issue and that we have a referendum on it in the first term of a Labor government.

The value of this issue and the importance of Parrtjima in communicating issues like this is priceless. I am not sure a cost benefit analysis would be able to therefore prove anything about the true value of the Parrtjima experience.

Mineral exploration on the way up
The Chandler project is not simply a salt project.
The primary purpose of the project is to mine salt in order to create a void to dispose of huge quantities of hazardous waste.

Be Sociable, Share!

A new way to support our journalism

We do not have a paywall. If you support our independent journalism you can make a financial contribution by clicking the red button below. This will help us cover expenses and sustain the news service we’ve been providing since 1994, in a locally owned and operated medium.

Erwin Chlanda, Editor