Tourism, salt and toxic waste, 780 metres below

By ERWIN CHLANDA

 

A towering banquet hall with crystal chandeliers. Boating in Venice-like canals. A cathedral. A grandiose stair case leading up a five story cavern supported by an intricate system of white pillars.

 

All this is 780 metres below ground where it is 26 degrees at all times, when above it may be 45 degrees or minus five.

 

It could happen here, just an hour’s drive from Alice Springs.

 

If telling a cracking good yarn can earn you a salt mine, Tellus managing director Duncan van der Merwe has what it takes, creating a challenge for of his critics, including Alex Read, policy officer of the Arid Lands Environment Centre (ALEC).

 

The planned mine called Chandler near the Aboriginal community of Titjikala will take out salt and put in hazardous waste, with income from visitors, in partnership with local operators, as a sideline, taking its lead from salt mine tourism in around 60 sites across Europe, 20 of them in Germany.

 

Tellus has a similar operation under construction in WA.

 

The Alice project is undergoing some changes: Rather than having a rail siding about 45 km west of the mine the rail-road transfer is proposed to happen at Brewer industrial estate 25 km south of Alice.

 

Tellus is putting $60m on the table for improving the very rough Maryvale Road, intending to seal the high-risk and medium-risk sections and upgrade the low-risk ones.

 

The company is talking to the Commonwealth and NT Government about putting in money “and there is interest,” says Mr van der Merwe.

 

While he says Tellus is keen to support local business, he is aware that NT road builders are far more expensive than those in Queensland and WA and he will be looking to get bang for his buck.

 

Using a rail siding west of the mine would have meant building a sealed private access road only half as long but it would have been useless for anyone else.

 

Titjikala and Alice Springs would benefit greatly from a sealed road between them, as many stakeholders have pointed out.

 

Salt mine tourism in Europe attracts two types of visitors: One to admire the magic created in the mines, some of them hundreds of years old, and the other to observe a modern mining operation – industrial tourism “is a mature industry in Europe,” says Mr van der Merwe.

 

It would open up tourism to the south of Alice, presently only featuring Chamber’s Pillar and Rainbow Valley, accessed from the east.

 

Mr van der Merwe says the mine could follow Red Bull’s lead staging running races and mountain bike competitions in the sprawling mine tunnels, boxing and wrestling contests, choir singing, symphony orchestra music.

 

“Australians are losing their connection to mining which generates immense wealth.”

 

All that is much less likely to succeed while the road remains usually in lousy condition. This has led to fatalities, and is demolishing the cars Aboriginal people are travelling in to receive dialysis in Alice.

 

Most significant to the Alice economy, says Mr van der Merwe, is that reducing the travel time from Alice from two hours to one, will bring the location within range of daily commuting for the 270 staff building the mine (not counting “indirects”), and 150 to 180 workers operating it in two shifts.

 

Mr Read is pictured at left in the photo, with Rick (no surname available), Jennifer Taylor and Barb Molanus, outside the NT Government office in The Mall where the briefings took place this week. (Photo supplied.)

 

Mr Read says there was not “enough information to make a properly informed decision on the full impacts of the modification [using Brewer].

 

“They were not able to tell us how many trucks would be moving, where the waste would be coming from and exactly what types of waste will be transported.

 

“Until  we know this detail we can’t make a properly informed decision about the impact the modification will have on the community of Alice Springs.

 

“The community of Alice Springs is entitled to more answers if they are being asked to become the dumping ground for Australia’s hazardous waste.”

 

Mr van der Merwe says the trucks will not enter Alice Springs. They will travel between Brewer, the South Stuart Highway turn-off near the airport, and from then go south along the Maryvale Road.

 

The closest they will come no closer to town than 10 kilometres.

 

Mr Read does not suggest that Tellus will be transporting and storing materials not permitted under NT legislation, but he has doubts that the legislation is appropriate and adequate. He says the Environmental Protection Authority is under-resourced.

 

He also suggests that mining companies are given to making big promises during negotiations for mining rights but once they are obtained go back on their word.

 

Says Mr Read: “We hear this all the time from mining companies. They always aspire to the best they can. And then we get closer towards final approvals and they say that wasn’t financially achievable, we had to modify our plans, it’s not technically possible, the government put limitations on us.

 

“We’re striving to employ as many locals as possible. We’re striving to create as much return to the local economy. It’s all part of their attempt to boost their image with the community, to manufacture consent for a project which they know full well is going to be deeply unpopular when people realise the scale they are proposing.”

 

Mr van der Merwe makes it clear that much of the tourism side will be an opportunity for local businesses to become involved in such ventures as restaurants, souvenir shops, tour guiding and hands-on participation in cutting and shaping the soft material.

 

The success of the operators will depend on their input, through micro businesses and cottage industries, salt rooms for salt therapies, gourmet salts which could connect with Aboriginal bush foods, says Mr van der Merwe: “This is very popular in Europe. It’s aimed at well-heeled tourists.

 

“Alice Springs could be seen as the salt capital of Australia.”

 

Mr Read has expressed concern about the possibility of temporary storage of containers at Brewer.

 

Mr van der Merwe says each pallet of waste is sealed in a double lined pack or in barrels, or other containers.

 

It is then cling-wrapped and sealed with kevlar tape before being put into a shipping container that is sealed and locked.

 

The shipping containers would be at Brewer for not more that 24 hours except for worst case scenarios such as floods in the Hugh River.

 

What is the nastiest thing that could possibly be stored there?

 

“Acetone. Nail polish remover,” says Mr Mr van der Merwe.

 

“Incredibly powerful chemical. We do not let our people near to acetone without full-blown protective equipment. Yet you can see people in beauty salons in Alice Springs using it without a mask.”

 

Will there be radioactive material?

 

“Absolutely not. Not at Chandler. We have definitively said this since day one.

 

“In our WA project, called Sandy Ridge, we will be able to take what is called naturally occurring radioactive materials up to low level waste, things like Xrays, smoke detectors, airport monitoring equipment you walk through, electric car batteries.

 

Neither facility will take nuclear waste: “It is against WA law.”

 

Mr Read says: “I don’t think there is going to be a market [for salt mine tourism] considering it is such a remote location.”

 

People will not “flock to” hazardous waste. “It does not match with the amenity or character of this place.”

 

Mr Read says the consultation meeting was poorly attended and not well advertised.

 

The facility is located here because it can be “out of sight, out of mind” of big cities.

 

Much of the waste could be recycled or re-purposed.

 

“The salt is not going to make them money. The money maker is the waste,” says Mr Read.

 

IMAGES from websites promoting salt mine tourism in Europe.

 

 

UPDATE October 29:

 

Town Council CEO Robert Jennings, when asked to comment, said he is waiting for more information on the Chandler mine before expressing any view or comment.

 

 

 

Be Sociable, Share!

A new way to support our journalism

We do not have a paywall. If you support our independent journalism you can make a financial contribution by clicking the red button below. This will help us cover expenses and sustain the news service we’ve been providing since 1994, in a locally owned and operated medium.

Erwin Chlanda, Editor


7 Comments (starting with the most recent)

NB: If you want to reply to a previous comment, start your comment with this notation: @n where n is the number of the comment you want to reply to.
  1. Liberal
    Posted October 29, 2019 at 9:28 pm

    Please build the mine. Alice Springs seriously needs some good news stories and this would be heaven!

    View Comment
  2. Travis Bruce
    Posted October 29, 2019 at 7:43 am

    If you are a blackfella and call yourself a traditional owner for Titjikala the answer is no. You fight against it till you can’t fight anymore. The country will wipe your family out. Open your eyes and look at the warning signs.

    View Comment
  3. Lyndsay Buckingham
    Posted October 28, 2019 at 1:21 pm

    The use of underground impermeable geologies (salt & clay) have been recognised for decades by governments, regulators, and the likes of the UN as the safest form of permanent isolation and disposal of difficult to manage waste streams around the world’
    This is why there are hundreds of these facilities operating across the globe as a worlds best practice solution.
    The WA government itself has been using a clay facility for decades to store their own difficult to manage waste problems. Tellus has been co-managing that facility for a number of years for the govt. For circa 25 years there has never been an incident at this facility.
    Australia already has an economic and environmental waste disaster … its called LANDFILL and they are located in high density communities and in many cases corruptly house hazardous waste materials exposing those communities to real atmospheric and water table pollution risks.
    Australia needs to develop safe and permanent commercial solutions to address our haz waste problems.
    The NT needs jobs. Contrary to this article there have been very few mining developments in the NT over the past 25 years.
    Tellus’ Chandler salt formation is located in a geological structure known as the Amadeus basin. Its located 700m underground, is 300m thick, and hasn’t moved for over 500 million years.
    The materials Tellus will house in its facility for the most part are far less of a danger compared to our daily transport of petroleum and gas products we transport amongst our metropolitan communities.
    Both the multi layer man made barriers Tellus will incorporate, coupled with the impermeable nature of a thick vast salt formation will permanently isolate any materials from the biosphere ie there is zero risk to even the nearest community.
    A claim that such a remote location (120km south of Alice Springs) in a geological formation 1 km below the earths surface is “in my backyard” is hardly an accurate statement.
    Mr Read appears to fail to understand that there are hazardous waste materials that are legally/illegally being stored within built up communities and being dumped in the likes of NT deserts.
    Tellus is bringing to Australia a far safer, greener, and lower cost solution. It will permanently dispose of difficult to manage waste streams until we can develop recycling processes that might turn these waste streams into a commercial asset, in which case they can recover those materials to create even more job opportunities and economic fortune for the NT community.
    Tellus has demonstrated over many years of patient development and highly transparent ethical and social standards in all of its 100s of community and govt engagements. Given its been a 10 year journey for them to finally be on the verge of its first commercial operations in WA, there has been zero evidence its just in it for the money or employs low ethical standards. There website is one of the most transparent and comprehensive sites I have observed.
    We should support projects that are actually SOLVING existing environmental problems and creating jobs. Not just put our heads in the sand and engage in conspiracy theories that are absent of any evidence or facts.

    View Comment
  4. Spot
    Posted October 28, 2019 at 5:56 am

    Interesting to still hear that WA has a similar operation under way but is it not still under the same restrictions it has had for many years now.
    WA can produce and ship radioactive products out of the state but are not allowing the return of any waste produced by this back into the state.
    So it means other parts of Australia has to be the waste dumps for them receiving all the benefit from the mining.
    This seems to be the issue with a very large pile of waste sitting in Asia now waiting for a new home.
    Let’s show a sight of transparency and honesty in this discussion.
    Have them build this road.
    First, before any further discussion, the locals can benefit by having a nice road to drive in and out to all further meetings and if it is found to be at later date a bit of smoke and mirrors at least a nice road would be left behind as a reminder.

    View Comment
  5. Climate voter
    Posted October 26, 2019 at 12:43 pm

    Tourism? What a red herring! Salt mining? Well that’s a good way to dig a hole in the ground. Toxic waste disposal?… a lucrative way of getting rid of unwanted, dangerous, contaminating, material. We don’t need this in central Australia, the residents of Tijikala don’t need this storage dump on their country. Do these companies think we’re stupid? We don’t want fracking in the NT, or anywhere. There are viable alternatives, and if the NT Gov was not tied up with big mining and big business, they’d be free to govern and develop the Territory in a sustainable, responsible way. Too late it seems.

    View Comment
  6. Jim Cleary
    Posted October 26, 2019 at 1:21 am

    A very interesting article. However I see no mention of the disposal of the toxic waste created by the fracking industry.
    As we all know there are thousands of gallons of water and unknown toxic chemicals pumped into the ground for the fracking of the rock with unknown amounts returning to the surface.
    Here in the US, one of the major concerns is the legal disposal of this toxic mix which include old salt mine caves.
    So, as per my question, will the fracking waste be considered for storage in the area in question?

    View Comment
  7. Patricia Beattie
    Posted October 25, 2019 at 1:46 pm

    The more provision we make for the storage of hazardous waste, the less the incentive to avoid creating it in the first place. I agree. It is the disposal of the waste which will bring in the money.

    View Comment

Post a Comment

Your email is never shared. Required fields are marked *

*
*