Buffel: Burgoyne puts cart before the cow

The incremental buffel grass expansion is expected to result in large net economic losses for the NT, with costs about sixty times greater than benefits, according to a CDU report.
Yet Minister for Environment Joshua Burgoyne (pictured with buffel) gave pastoralists in effect carte blanche to buy, propagate and use the weed before the report, which he had commissioned, had been released.
The report says: "The benefits of forage provision [fodder] and erosion-control are estimated at just $112.3/ha/year, whereas the corresponding per-hectare external costs are at $6,328/ha/year.
"They are driven predominantly by biodiversity loss, cultural-site degradation, fire-regime intensification, buffel grass management burdens, and scenic amenity decline.
"Thereby, each additional hectare of buffel grass-dominated landscape imposes close to $6,216/ha/year in external costs.
"These findings are consistent across all scenarios, time horizons, and discount rates."
Meanwhile Mr Burgoyne announced "action through a $750,000 annual commitment and delivering the Buffel Grass Weed Management Plan 2026-36.
"This plan highlights the need for further investment – which is why I have written to the Federal Government seeking additional investment from the Commonwealth to support buffel grass management across the Northern Territory.
“This report reinforces the need for the Federal Government and Alice Springs Town Council to work together with our Government to manage buffel grass into the future.”
Mr Burgoyne said the assessment recognised the economic importance of existing buffel grass pastures, with grazing on these pastures remaining an important land use across many NT pastoral regions.
UPDATE September 1, 2026
The NT Cattlemen’s Association has announced that it had identified "serious concerns with the methodology, calculations, assumptions, stakeholder balance and quality-assurance processes" underpinning the CDU report.
CEO Romy Carey says in its current form it should not be relied upon to direct government policy or regulatory decisions.
“The fundamental concern is that the assessment appears to apply different standards to each side of the ledger.
"Pastoral benefits are treated narrowly, while environmental, cultural, fire-management and other costs are considered much more broadly.
"The pastoral contribution of buffel grass is largely reduced to an annual production value, despite the report acknowledging other material benefits including drought resilience, standing feed security, reduced reliance on supplementary feeding, enterprise stability and increased productive capacity of pastoral land."




4 comments
Marie Purvis
Unfortunately for all the anti buffel grass brigade, Minister Burgoyne`s decision on the buffel grass management plan was the rational way to go.
It would be foolish to put too much credence in the CDU report. It seems they began with the agenda to denigrate buffel grass. To support their theory they devised a rather lengthy online survey with all questions biased against buffel grass.
To get a more balanced view on the topic people should read Dr Friedel`s recently published article. Dr Friedel is an Australian rangeland and management researcher. She has researched in depth the arrival of the buffel grasses in Australia, their spread and its impact on our environment, warts and all.
From this and our own observations over the years buffel grass doesn't seem to be anywhere near as devastating as the CDU report predicts.
The CDU report is light on facts and heavy on assumptions and appears to have been quickly cobbled together by the anti buffel grass conspirators. I just hope not too much taxpayers money was expended on it.
I believe Minister Burgoyne has the Territory at heart and has made the correct call for our collective future.
Ralph Folds
Your use of Dr Margaret Friedel’s research to support your case against the CDU report is misleading.
Dr Friedel certainly recognises that buffel grass has economic value, particularly to the pastoral industry. But that does amount to an endorsement of the claim that buffel grass is "nowhere near as devastating" as the CDU report suggests.
Quite the contrary: Dr Friedel has described buffel grass as a serious environmental weed and has researched its effects on fire regimes and native vegetation.
Her work presents a nuanced picture — buffel has benefits, but it also has serious environmental consequences. It does not provide scientific justification for dismissing concerns about buffel grass, let alone for labelling those who raise them "anti-buffel conspirators".If you believe the CDU report is wrong, you should challenge its evidence and methodology.
Invoking Dr Friedel’s name does not make your own conclusions hers.
Dr Friedel’s research deserves to be represented accurately, not selectively used to support a position she has not actually taken.
[ED – The Alice Springs News doesn't make a "case" except when we clearly label a piece we write COMMENT. On this occasion we quoted the CDU, the Cattlemen's Association and the Minister, and published three letters to the editor (so far), one of which mentioned Dr Friedel. That was the writer's choice, well within the bounds of our mission of being a forum for public comment.]Adrian Tomlinson
This a public policy failure of mind-blowing proportions.
The economic impact assessment found:
1. The cost of buffel grass’s spread is approximately 60 times its benefits.
2. Pastoral leaseholders perceive tangible economic benefits (note claims of erosion control benefits are unsubstantiated and dubious) but they do so with significant externalised costs.
NT Environment Minister Joshua Burgoyne was foolhardy when he jumped ahead of this economic impact assessment with his Buffel Grass Weed management Plan. This economic impact assessment was commissioned to inform the weed management plan.
Instead Minister Burgoyne rushed ahead and released a draft weed management plan that:
1. allows buffel to be planted and spread by the pastoral industry;
2. does not recover costs from those who derive a perceived benefit.
Staggeringly, the draft weed management plan the Minister released for public comment was not even the version recommended by the majority of his Buffel Grass Weed Advisory Committee members. He chose a weaker alternative recommended to him by a minority of "pastoral members" that allowed buffel to be keep being spread.
The Minister then stuck his neck out even further by ignoring the significant public opposition to the draft (75% of submissions). He gazetted a Buffel Grass Weed Management Plan that was very similar to the draft. It still allowed buffel grass to be planted and spread by the pastoral industry.
This triggered a wave of wreath laying at his doorstop by people not normally seen at protests. This reflected the community heartache and the scale of his mistake.
Buffel grass’s spread is a tragedy of epic proportions. The costs of fires and biodiversity, cultural, business and scenic amenity losses are enormous. In many cases the losses are unrecoverable.
This buffel grass economic impact assessment emphatically shows the Minister has failed badly and been fiscally irresponsible. He should not have rushed the Buffel Grass Weed Management Plan. He should have waited for this economic impact assessment as planned. He should have heeded his advisory committee’s advice like normal. He should have listened to his upset constituents.
When a Minister steps goes so far out on a limb, they must take full responsibility for the outcomes.
Minister Burgoyne did not heed the warnings or follow good process. The Minister should now resign.
Jo
I've lived out bush and in Alice Springs for 50 years. When we lived out on the Plenty Highway everything was dirt, huge dust storms were a daily occurrence and filled our bathtub inside with red dust.
Driving back home after being in Alice Springs was terrible if we got caught in a dust storm, the dirt was so dense that we would have to stop by the side of the (dirt) road and wait for the storm to die down.
The holes everywhere from rabbits and erosion from rain and more dust storms were epic, I think that if people were taught to not start fires, we wouldn’t have any problems.