NATS benefit to economy open to question

2482 brunout NATS OK

 

Burnout image from the NATS website.

 

By ERWIN CHLANDA

 

While deploring the Territory’s reduced revenue from GST, and the resulting billion dollar plus deficit, Chief Minister Michael Gunner has no problem with spending $1.3m for a two and a half day motoring event, justified by claims of major benefits to the local economy that are open to question.

 

Mr Gunner continues the unconvincing assertions by his predecessor, Adam Giles, that people “through the gate” equals individuals attending, a line fed to them by the Major Events organisation which is a statutory body of the NT Government.

 

This year’s Red Centre NATS, the second in the series for which Mr Giles entered into a six year agreement with an interstate company, is an ongoing case in point.

 

The morning after the tragic events which concluded this year’s fixture Mr Gunner held a press conference in Alice Springs.

 

After a question from the ABC about whether the event would continue – Mr Gunner replied there were no plans to cancel it – the Alice Springs News Online asked (see video): “How many people does it bring into the town?”

 

GUNNER: That’s a very good question that Major Events might be able to comment on, the exact attendance numbers [now addressing Andrew Hopper, general manager of the company, who was present] – Andrew …

 

2480 Andrew Hopper 1 OKHOPPER (pictured at right): Total attendance was about 14,000.

 

GUNNER: 14,000.

 

NEWS: Is that 14,000 different people or 14,000 through the gate?

 

HOPPER: Through the gate.

 

NEWS: That’s a different thing, Chief Minister. One person could go through five gates [during the course of the event].

 

GUNNER: We can work with you about these details, if you like. But it draws people from around the country.

 

We are still waiting for that work to happen, despite emailed requests (on September 13 – 10 days after the event – and on September 20)  to Mr Hopper, asking: “How many individuals attended the NATS? How many were from outside Alice Springs? And how long did those stay in town?

 

“How many events were there between scrutineering on Wednesday and the Podium Party on Sunday, at different times and locations?

 

“As I understand it, each of them has a ‘gate’  though which people passed whose number you have already given – 14,000.”

 

Mr Hopper replied: “We are in the process of finalising when we release information about the event as part of the wrap up.

 

“The delay is out of respect for the injured parties.

 

“Until we release any information publicly we will not be providing the numbers you require as you will in effect have information which we are not ready to release publicly.

 

“Some of the information you require we only collect via the post event survey and the distribution of this has also been delayed out of respect for the injured parties.”

 

Mr Hopper does not explain how withholding accurate information about the event constitutes respect for the injured, while he freely circulates the 14,000 which allows no reliable conclusions about the benefits to the local economy.

 

The News estimated there were 2000 people at Blatherskite Park at the form-up of the street parade. Did anyone see 14,000 people at any one time on the viewing hill overlooking the drags start? If there are three gates, does that make the actual number of people attending 4700? If there are five gates were there actually 2800?

 

Meanwhile the NT News in Darwin swallowed Mr Hopper’s spin, hook, line and sinker: “They came to Alice Springs from all over — around 14,000 rev heads from all corners of the country enticed to the red centre by the promise of burning rubber,” the Murdoch paper reported.

 

For the NT News, not only were there 14,000 individual people at the Red Centre NATS, they all came from outside Alice Springs.

 

 

 

 

 

Be Sociable, Share!

5 Comments (starting with the most recent)

NB: If you want to reply to a previous comment, start your comment with this notation: @n where n is the number of the comment you want to reply to.
  1. Erwin Chlanda
    Posted October 2, 2017 at 2:26 am

    Hi Gabs and Brent: We’re not denying that local businesses benefitted from the NATS. We’re just demanding accurate figures about the extent of that benefit.

    As taxpayers I’m sure you would like that information as well. We’ll do our best to bring it to you.

    Erwin Chlanda, Editor, Alice Springs News Online

    View Comment
  2. Brent
    Posted October 2, 2017 at 12:07 am

    Center NATS brings a fortune into town. Businesses all over town benefit. From hotels to petrol stations and souvenir shops. Even tourism ventures get a boost.
    How much did that stupid light show cost? Because not a single extra visitor came for it. It should be noted that Center NATS costs less than a third of what the CAFL football finals cost, and the only industry that gets more work on the back of the finals is the court docket.

    View Comment
  3. Charlie Carter
    Posted October 1, 2017 at 3:44 pm

    Yes Erwin, as I have written elsewhere: “Territorians need more than ‘bread and circuses’ from their Government,” but all we got is a couple of circuses, not even some bread.
    These taxpayer funded circuses are always justified as bringing hundreds of thousands of dollars without any solid evidence.
    I very much doubt anyone came to the Centre to see the light show. Naturally a few that were coming anyway went to see it, but that doesn’t constitute extra dollars.
    As for the NATS I don’t think my tax dollars should be spent so that silly people can destroy expensive tyres creating massive stink, noise and pollution.
    And I’m not just a basket weaving greenie, I still ride a motorcycle (at 71).
    Even with the few hundred (my estimate) who came for the NATS, the main benefit probably went to the big accommodation places, most of which are interstate owned. And now tax payer subsidised.
    If the local hoons want to destroy tyres, and silly people want to watch them, I’m sure they can do it locally (organised and off street) without tax payer funding.

    View Comment
  4. Gabs
    Posted October 1, 2017 at 12:50 pm

    I think you’re forgetting that these people spend thousands of dollars whilst visiting our town.
    The hotels and caravan parks are full, restaurants are full, supermarkets and petrol stations do a roaring trade.
    It’s not necessarily about numbers through the gate.

    View Comment
  5. Bruce
    Posted September 30, 2017 at 12:36 pm

    On this the weekend of the footy finals, no less: George Orwell in his book 1984: “Films, football, beer, and above all, gambling filled up the horizon of their minds. To keep them in control was not difficult …” Now add the idiot box into the mix.
    Yep, Bread and circuses indeed, Erwin. Each one pushing the previous one out of the way. All surviving on local (Council), Territory and Federal funding for their existence.
    It’s as much about funding to travelling (whitefella) artists and local arts organisations as it is to tourism.
    You’d be excused for believing the money supply was endless.

    View Comment

Post a Comment

Your email is never shared. Required fields are marked *

*
*